The suspension bushes on my MK are very tight. I've read through numerous posts trying to come up with a solution but have not found a definitive
answer.
I've done about 2000 miles on them and they creaked from day 1.
I'm in the process of rebuilding the car currently and cannot get the crush tubes to rotate freely enough.
Here's what I have done so far -
Ground down the weld on the inside of the wishbone tube.
Sanded off all the powder coating.
Removed any burrs from the bushes and crush tubes.
Installed using lithium ep2 grease.
The crush tubes rotate freely in the bush when they are out of the wishbone, so the bush is getting crushed too much.
Should I purchase a 3/4" reamer to open up the bushes once fitted?
Cheers
Matt.
Common problem is the crush tube is too short , easy to test assemble the bushes and crush tube then nip the crush tube in a vice, the wishbone should rotate around the crush tube under its own weight . Skimming the outside of the larger diameter of the bush worked for me .
quote:
Originally posted by rusty nuts
Common problem is the crush tube is too short , easy to test assemble the bushes and crush tube then nip the crush tube in a vice, the wishbone should rotate around the crush tube under its own weight . Skimming the outside of the larger diameter of the bush worked for me .
quote:
Originally posted by mk7matt
Ground down the weld on the inside of the wishbone tube.
The crush tubes are slightly longer than the bush.
The problem I've got is its too tight when pushed into the bush, without it even fitted on the car.
There is no way it would drop under its own weight when bolted up.
Would it be a better idea to reduce the diameter of the crush tube rather than ream the bush?
This way each crush tube would be custom fitted to the bush.
quote:
Originally posted by Slimy38
Just to pick this out on it's own, the bushes should rotate 'with' the wishbone tube. It should only rotate around the crush tube. Some builders actually roughen the inner surface of the wishbone tube (I think Talon's wishbone tubes are rough cut inside?) to allow the bush to move only against the crush tube.
But I think you're on the right track with the crush tubes being too short. If necessary you could file down the wishbone outer tube which would allow the crush tubes to be slightly longer in relation to it.
Have you tried nipping the assembled wishbone as I suggested to be absolutely sure ?
Ah, now I get you.
You've only done 2000 miles so I might be wrong, but have the bushes swelled up? I'm nowhere near the same place with my build so I'm
working with 'fresh' bushes, I'm sure someone on here suggested that cheaper bushes swell over time.
(Or is it perhaps a reaction to some lubricants? Not sure, I'm working off my bad memory here... )
quote:
Originally posted by Slimy38
Ah, now I get you.
You've only done 2000 miles so I might be wrong, but have the bushes swelled up? I'm nowhere near the same place with my build so I'm working with 'fresh' bushes, I'm sure someone on here suggested that cheaper bushes swell over time.
(Or is it perhaps a reaction to some lubricants? Not sure, I'm working off my bad memory here... )
If you can get hold of the original measurements for the bush, then a few minutes with a vernier caliper might reveal something?
Or even measuring them against the wishbone tube and crush tube to see exactly how much of the quart you're squeezing into a pint pot?
[Edited on 10/2/16 by Slimy38]
Just curious
Are you lads tightening the wishbones up with the car on its wheels and on the ground ?
Or up in the air with the weight of the car off the ground ?
Ok, been out to the garage to have a measure.
Unfitted bush
OD is 28.7mm ish
ID is 19.1mm ish
Fitted bush
ID is 18.9mm ish
Crush tube is 19.0mm
Wishbone is 28.6mm ish
To me these measurements seem ok. I did notice that the bushes were out of round though, possibly caused by the seam weld in the wishbone tube.
Should I bite the bullet and buy new bushes?
Are the ones on eBay any good?
quote:
Originally posted by perksy
Just curious
Are you lads tightening the wishbones up with the car on its wheels and on the ground ?
Or up in the air with the weight of the car off the ground ?
quote:
Originally posted by mk7matt
quote:
Originally posted by perksy
Just curious
Are you lads tightening the wishbones up with the car on its wheels and on the ground ?
Or up in the air with the weight of the car off the ground ?
I didn't think it mattered due to the design of the bush?
We're talking about the two part polyurethane bush with crush tube not the triumph style rubber bush.
I wouldn't recommend Duraflex bushes off E-Bay,returned mine as sizes and quality were awful.
Got some now off Danny at MK,much better bush.
I have read you should not use petroleum based greases with polyurethane,lithium based grease is ok
quote:
Originally posted by CosKev3
One thing I would be careful of,grinding down the ERW weld inside the tube,fingers crossed on yours it's between the welds onto the wishbone tube?
quote:
Originally posted by perksy
Just curious
Are you lads tightening the wishbones up with the car on its wheels and on the ground ?
Or up in the air with the weight of the car off the ground ?
I won't go over the same ground that's already covered in this thread (and others) but instead would like to
mention a couple of other points.
When the wishbone is welded the outer bush tube will shrink and become out of round. The bushes may have
been a perfect fit before welding but they won't be afterwards.
If the bushes are then forced into the now shrunken and misshapen tube the bush will be compressed, and
therefore the i/d will be less, resulting in the binding of the crush tube inside it.
The answer is to ream AFTER the insertion of the bushes. I did mine on the lathe to ensure perfect alignment.
Hope this helps,
Paul G
Thanks Paul G.
I'll be ordering a reamer then.
Good point Paul.
Perhaps I should also add a quote from post 3 from Bluemoon.
quote
"But first off the crush tubes need to be the correct length for the brackets, and slightly longer than the bush assembly.
Dan"
end quote
A combination of reaming and compatible component lengths result in the "free fall" of the wishbone under it's own weight.
IMHO, the binding of polybushes is THE major cause of failures in wishbones.
Cheers
Paul G
My understanding is that the crush tube needs to be slightly longer than the distance between the outer faces of the bush halves. This prevents the
suspension bracket from squashing and trapping the bush preventing it rotating freely around the crush tube. I believe the bush halves should be a
relatively tight fit in the wishbone as you don't want them to rotate in the wishbone, but rotate around the crush tube without squeaking. On my
MK Indy I used to remove the bushes annually and re-grease them to ensure free movement without squeaks.
Some people seem to fit grease nipple in the wishbone tubes. Myself I feel this could weaken the wishbone tube and is best avoided.
quote:
Originally posted by 907
IMHO, the binding of polybushes is THE major cause of failures in wishbones.
Cheers
Paul G
" From Nick,
My understanding is that the crush tube needs to be slightly longer than the distance between the outer faces of the bush halves. This prevents the
suspension bracket from squashing and trapping the bush preventing it rotating freely around the crush tube. I believe the bush halves should be a
relatively tight fit in the wishbone as you don't want them to rotate in the wishbone, but rotate around the crush tube without squeaking. On my
MK Indy I used to remove the bushes annually and re-grease them to ensure free movement without squeaks. "
The above is exactly how ive done mine, the poly bush needs to be a firm fit, and still needed to be pressed in
I cleaned up the inside wall with a small grinding wheel on the drill, so you do not need a reamer, unless a lot of metal needs to removed, and that
would cause a failure in itself, too much metal was removed
The centre crush tube needs to be slightly longer than the overall length of the two bushes and suspension tube
In my application, the crush tube was 42mm long, and the bushes plus suspension tube came to 41.5mm
and even that was a nice tight fit when greased,
My suspension arms do not fall naturally, but will do very easily when moved by hand, and rest in the "left" position
steve
quote:
Originally posted by steve m
The above is exactly how ive done mine, the poly bush needs to be a firm fit, and still needed to be pressed in
I cleaned up the inside wall with a small grinding wheel on the drill, so you do not need a reamer, unless a lot of metal needs to removed, and that would cause a failure in itself, too much metal was removed
steve
quote:
Originally posted by mk7matt
quote:
Originally posted by steve m
The above is exactly how ive done mine, the poly bush needs to be a firm fit, and still needed to be pressed in
I cleaned up the inside wall with a small grinding wheel on the drill, so you do not need a reamer, unless a lot of metal needs to removed, and that would cause a failure in itself, too much metal was removed
steve
I think there may be a bit of misunderstanding here.
I'm planning on reaming the bush once it's fitted inside the wishbone tube so that the crush tube fits nicely.
I'll report back on Wednesday when the reamer turns up.
Reamer turned up early
Seems to do the trick. It's an adjustable type, so I just removed a little at a time until the crush tube fitted with a little resistance.
Bolted the wishbone up to the chassis and it's much better. It almost falls under its own weight now.
Thank you to all who have posted.
I look forward to a creak free, better handling car.
Cheers
Matt
[Edited on 15/2/16 by mk7matt]