Board logo

threads on a track rodend.
JoelP - 17/2/06 at 08:06 PM

having finally put the new rack in the locost, i find that, even with a touch of toe in, i only have 5 threads holding the TREs on. Definately borderline, but with the locknuts they seem snug. Question is, is that too few turns? They arent short enough to fit extensions, which rather annoyingly, i have lying around...

any thoughts?


flak monkey - 17/2/06 at 08:09 PM

If you have 5 turns you have about 9mm of thread in the track rod. Which i would say isnt enough, but i am happy to be proven wrong!

david


Nick Skidmore - 17/2/06 at 08:11 PM

I would say that's not enough. 1.5 x diameter is comfortable.

How about cutting the trackrod at a suitable place and welding a sleeve made out of tube / drilled bar over the gap?

I've seen single seater drive shafts shotened / lengthened by this method.


JoelP - 17/2/06 at 08:19 PM

well, i just did that with the column, and i suppose the rack sees different but smaller forces than the column.

Are the arms normal steel?


andyb64 - 17/2/06 at 08:40 PM

Joel, if you need anything machining you can use my lathe if you want

Andy...


JoelP - 17/2/06 at 08:59 PM

cheers andy - not sure what im going to make to sort this one. Having just been for a blast round the block, the toe in is excessive - rolling out of the drive saw the tyres jumping every few metres.

I have some 19mm round bar, but it seems a little thin and wouldnt be a tight fit. Maybe a 4 inch sleeve with regular holes drilled for spot welds.

Any tips anyone? It needs sorting tomorrow, as its trackday sunday, hence i cant buy any parts.

That said, the quick rack makes an amazing difference! Unbelieveable Just need some new top bones and some new shocks now


Jon Ison - 17/2/06 at 09:35 PM

Dunno if this will make any sense ?

If you have some round bar, cut your track rods in half ish, drill n tap up the middle, (lathe is best) drill n tap up the middle of your extension piece (the round bar) prob around M8 for all of them, use some threaded bar (studding) or cut some bolt heads off if you have none, put a weld prep on all the bits your gonna screw together and screw the lot together then fill the weld preps with weld and too make it really neat back in lathe too smooth it all off.

Hope this makes some kinda sense, if anyone is wondering if this will hold I have made input shafts this way too mate different engine/gearbox combinations together driving thru a locked diff so seeing lots of load and never broke one........ touch wood.


Edit too add,

Nothing wrong with the sleeve idea above, ive done drive shafts that way too, just think the idea I mentioned looks much neater especially if done in a lathes

[Edited on 17/2/06 by Jon Ison]


gazza285 - 17/2/06 at 10:16 PM

Why not cut the ends off your track rod to allow you to put the extensions on? Or will you cut off too much thread to leave you with not enough in the extension then.


JoelP - 17/2/06 at 10:28 PM

hi guys. Lots of good ideas, but heres my best attempt, hot from the welder. No time to spare! I must confess, i held it at the most photogenic angle!

I found some 15mm tube, chopped 20mms of it, chopped the arms, welded the 15mm into the gap, then ground back and sleeved it with the 19mm round, which turned out to be a tight fit.

Thoughts? Rescued attachment rackend1.JPG
Rescued attachment rackend1.JPG


JoelP - 17/2/06 at 10:30 PM

a slightly lighter photo, so the welds actually show up... Rescued attachment racklight.JPG
Rescued attachment racklight.JPG


JoelP - 17/2/06 at 10:32 PM

balls that no better. Rescued attachment racklight.JPG
Rescued attachment racklight.JPG


02GF74 - 18/2/06 at 10:50 AM

Christ almighty!!! Have you not been paying attentions? I have this problem; quick search would reveal all.

To answer some questions;
The track rods are hardened steel (rally design) so it would be next to impossible to cut threads using a die; you need a lathe.

Ford rack, if my old one is one. has 12 mm rods and the threads on the ends are rolled to make them 14 mm. You could put 12 mm thread on but thatwont match the track rod ends.

In my case, I have about 3 threads engaging in the track rod end.

My solution is to have a set of short extensions made up, about 8 mm.

I have worked out that I would need to cur the track rods and they will screw into the extensions by about 27 mm.

Note that Rally design do similar ones to my design, for £20, in ali, DAR 006, diemensions (from memory) are

thredead end: 20 mm
solid end 5 mm
threaded hole: 40 mm (?)

As for what you have done,

From being on Land Rover forums, strengthening track rods comes up quite often and MOT man does not like any welding stuff on them; like what you have done, hmmmm....


JoelP - 18/2/06 at 11:38 AM

im not cutting threads, i welded a simple extension in. Its solid as f*ck, and steering arms arent that stressed anyway. Talk about paranoid...


JoelP - 18/2/06 at 11:42 AM

just to clarify my statement that they arent very stressed - i can steer the wheel by hand no problems, without the car being jacked up. I can also rotate it by hand, again, not jacked up. So if its that easy with dry steering, how much easier is it when the wheel is spinning? Centrifugal forces and bumps arent much greater.

Do you think you could even bend an arm by hand, nevermind stretch or compress it?


chrisg - 18/2/06 at 11:49 AM

Aren't welded trackrods an automatic MOT fail?

I always thought they were.

cheers

Chris


02GF74 - 18/2/06 at 12:15 PM

quote:
Originally posted by chrisg
Aren't welded trackrods an automatic MOT fail?

I always thought they were.

cheers

Chris


Did you read the second part of my post? ^^^^^ This what I thought as well.


chrisg - 18/2/06 at 12:44 PM

I didn't see that mate!

Anybody know for sure?

Cheers

Chris


rusty nuts - 18/2/06 at 12:58 PM

Sure welded track rods are an M.O.T AND S.V.A failure . Don't matter how strong you think they are . This problem seems to crop up now and then, anyone know of any company that can make extended track rods for not too much money ?


chrisg - 18/2/06 at 01:23 PM

Anyone with a decent lathe should be able to make them, tapped hole one end, thread turned on the other.

Cheers

Chris


JoelP - 18/2/06 at 01:34 PM

the welded part is under the rubber gaitor/boot thingy, plus its probably track only from now on anyway.

First shakedown is fine...


rusty nuts - 18/2/06 at 01:35 PM

Chris , I meant the complete track rod, not just the extensions . trouble is the ball on the inner end would need to be hardened?


chrisg - 18/2/06 at 01:41 PM

Yes it would.

I've found the bit from the mot test manual.

MOT Testers manual

Section C > d.

Cheers

Chris


flak monkey - 18/2/06 at 01:43 PM

Yep the balls are hardened. If you made them out of the right grade of steel (so you could heat treat the ball) and made a form tool to cut the ball accurately then you could make them at home... Not worth the hassle though really.

Easier to take the track rod off, cut it to shorten it, then put it in a lathe and turn the OD to a decent sizes so a nice accurate thread can be cut on it. Then make up some threaded extensions. IMO

David


britishtrident - 18/2/06 at 01:46 PM

Strikes me there is a big market for track rod extension with with 14 mm male thread and either untapped or 1/2" unf thread at the female end.


Sierra track rods ends are slightly longer but also because of the swan neck design alow the rack track rods to runs straighter --- which should allow them to screw on a few more threads.


britishtrident - 18/2/06 at 01:48 PM

I wonder if it would be possible to machine an Escort rackt to accept Sierra style track rods -


Nick Skidmore - 18/2/06 at 02:21 PM

If someone can do a sketch / drawing I'll make a pair, photograph them and post it here.

If there's enough interest I'll see what price the can be made at.

Any good?


JoelP - 18/2/06 at 03:14 PM

threaded extensions wouldnt have helped me with this one, i have a set anyway. I only needed 20mm adding, which is too little to do without chopping some off.

The long and short of it is it works fine welding it, the only problem being MOT time. I'll just put the original ones back in then, and crawl down with 3 threads holding them on.

Does anyone have a good reason why welding them isnt safe, rather than not legal? They are only steel afterall.


Jon Ison - 18/2/06 at 04:30 PM

Joel, if its under the gaiter out of sight forget about it.


britishtrident - 18/2/06 at 04:32 PM

The idea with 1/2" unf female extension is that the Escort rack track rods won't allow cutting 14 mm threads but should be OK at 1/2" UNF -- get my drift

They woud also be very handy for builders wanting to use MK1 Escort racks or Triumph racks.

[Edited on 18/2/06 by britishtrident]


Peteff - 18/2/06 at 05:38 PM

Mk1 track rod ends don't fit the Cortina or Sierra taper do they?


JoelP - 18/2/06 at 05:40 PM

well, its still in one piece. Tomorrow will be the real proof i guess.

All i need to do now is finish the trailer overnight to get it there!


britishtrident - 18/2/06 at 08:33 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Peteff
Mk1 track rod ends don't fit the Cortina or Sierra taper do they?


The idea was the female thread would be 1/2" and male 14mm to allow mk1 racks to be adapted to mk2 track rod ends or with use a die to put 1/2" threads on the mk2 Escort which is too small a dia to accept a cut 14mm thread.