Board logo

Help me choose a new car
carpmart - 23/6/15 at 05:55 PM

Chaps

I'm in a relatively fortuitous position financially at present and wanted to buy a 'new' car to replace my current daily driver. I run an old 2007 E60 M5 V10 and do around 15k miles per annum in it. I love it, but its got 106k on it now and i'm getting a little nervous about putting many more on there regularly.

I've looked at every 'reasonably sensible' daily driver and have narrowed it down to three options, with around a £50k budget.

An F10 M5
Nissan GTR
911

Thats it really. My sadness is loosing normal aspiration 8250 RPM red line, limiter deleted and remapped 560bhp and the Hayward and Scott exhaust system on the V10, which just sounds glorious...

My kids are grown up and the wifes car acts as the 'sensible' weekend hack if needed.

I'm heavily inclined towards staying with the 5 series as I had 2 e39's previously, which I loved. My bother has the 535d F10, which drives very nice, so I'm sold on the platform.

I've never owned a Porsche and the GTR appeals on lost of levels, but I'm worried its a little 'young' for me and a different class to the others.

I know this is a nice conundrum to have, but would just appreciate views and opinions on each.


gaz_gaz - 23/6/15 at 06:08 PM

Used to run a V10 M5 with Einsmann exhaust. Intakes and remap as a daily
Tried a few things including a 996 turbo and a Cayman R but I missed the noise. Looked at a GTR but in the end I got a V8 Vantage with Capristo system and carbon intakes.. big big noise now. Makes the M5 seem sedate by comparison!!


jeffw - 23/6/15 at 06:35 PM

checks the forum name....yeap, thought so

I'd go with the Locost GTR...because


morcus - 23/6/15 at 06:48 PM

Can't really help but would like to have your dilemma. I'd be swayed by the Porsche of the three but I'd be looking at an XK or a 6 series.


vonmoogen - 23/6/15 at 07:16 PM

Have you though about a maserati granturismo S? I bought one last year and love it. If you like loud cars you won't tire of opening up the exhaust flaps. Has to be one of the loudest factory exhausts!!!!!


Ugg10 - 23/6/15 at 07:29 PM

Just beat me to it, maser grand tourismo gets my vote, the later 4.2 na version, in dark grey with dark red interior.

Gtr is the sensible choice.

Noble m12 / m400 would be interesting as would a v8 vantage.

Or wait a year and the v8 jag f type will be down to that price.

Always worth a browse through the bramleys Web site for ideas.

I envy your dilema!

[Edited on 23/6/15 by Ugg10]


Pojo - 23/6/15 at 08:06 PM

[Edited on 24/6/15 by Pojo]


sdh2903 - 23/6/15 at 08:23 PM

It's automotive related so it's fine by me. Seriously some people get off your high horses. If you ain't got a constructive o
opinion then don't post.

F10 is a stonking car but very undramatic. I would go an have a look see at a 911. Reliable and very well screwed together. Either that or how about a 1m?


femster87 - 23/6/15 at 08:30 PM

Love it, I will be getting the new jaguar ftype if I have that sum burning a hole in my pocket. Seriously though, do you want to adopt me and insure me on whatever car you get??


gaz_gaz - 23/6/15 at 08:31 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Pojo
In my world a sensible daily drive does not have a £50,000 budget. A house extension has that budget. I will look at other forums for a realistic real world input. I do not begrudge you your position as I am sure you have worked hard for it BUT a lot of people on this forum participate with a view of building a performance vehicle at a low cost as per forum name I personally do not believe that you are portraying this and this question is more suited to Piston Heads. This will be my last and only comment. Goodbye.


Be serious.
There are plenty of locost as per the name of this forum cars knocking round that have had upto and beyond 30k spent building them..

I see no harm in the question, it's a car forum after all.
It's the "recommend me a toaster" topics I get annoyed about.
Surely there's a forum for toaster buyers?


gaz_gaz - 23/6/15 at 08:31 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Pojo
In my world a sensible daily drive does not have a £50,000 budget. A house extension has that budget. I will look at other forums for a realistic real world input. I do not begrudge you your position as I am sure you have worked hard for it BUT a lot of people on this forum participate with a view of building a performance vehicle at a low cost as per forum name I personally do not believe that you are portraying this and this question is more suited to Piston Heads. This will be my last and only comment. Goodbye.


Be serious.
There are plenty of locost as per the name of this forum cars knocking round that have had upto and beyond 30k spent building them..

I see no harm in the question, it's a car forum after all.
It's the "recommend me a toaster" topics I get annoyed about.
Surely there's a forum for toaster buyers?


carpmart - 23/6/15 at 09:20 PM

I'm a car guy, not trying to be a smart arse or anything... I'm aware that 50k would buy an extension, and if that's what you want, then go ahead and buy one. I love cars and spend my income disproportionately in this regard.

TBH, I would love an exotic, Lambo/Ferrari etc, but I need a car I can drive every day and park up. I also can't afford one... I love having the performance, but with a little subtlety in the clothing department.


Pojo - 23/6/15 at 09:32 PM

[Edited on 24/6/15 by Pojo]


jeffw - 23/6/15 at 09:33 PM

Audi R8....all the go without all the flash...



https://vimeo.com/57094832

[Edited on 23/6/15 by jeffw]


bi22le - 23/6/15 at 09:35 PM

3 quite different cars in my eyes. A luxury "barge", a 2 seater 'ring eater and a happy jappy piece of plastic.

Maybe try to look deeper into what you want and expect to get.

As we repeat time and time again to newbies. Get yourself along to a show and sit in some cars!!

£50K is not a huge amount to spend on a car. The amount of spanking new 40K cars on the roads these days is crazy.


jeffw - 23/6/15 at 09:44 PM

"happy jappy piece of plastic..."

You've obviously never been in or driven a GTR


daniel mason - 23/6/15 at 10:09 PM

I have. And almost shat myself!


bi22le - 23/6/15 at 10:48 PM

quote:
Originally posted by jeffw
"happy jappy piece of plastic..."

You've obviously never been in or driven a GTR


I wrote that with you in mind Jeff! Yes i have been in one and yes they don't compare to the other two cars for cabin build quality.

Next. . .


carpmart - 23/6/15 at 10:51 PM

I really am most likely to get the F10, but no one seems to love it?


jeffw - 24/6/15 at 05:17 AM

It is pretty 'ordinary' compared to the other options. If the choice was between that and the Audi RS6 or E Class AMG then maybe (although I'd take the RS6) but if you can get/run a GTR or an AM Vantage/Audi R8 then I'd do something else with my £50k


daniel mason - 24/6/15 at 06:20 AM

You could always put around half that money into a really nice car and use the other half to pump into a competition car and come play with us guys all summer! You could get a cracking radical pr6 for £20k or even go to single seaters! They will make all the above seem very slow/mundane


carpmart - 24/6/15 at 08:03 AM

quote:
Originally posted by daniel mason
You could always put around half that money into a really nice car and use the other half to pump into a competition car and come play with us guys all summer! You could get a cracking radical pr6 for £20k or even go to single seaters! They will make all the above seem very slow/mundane


Got my clubsport for that! I need a car to drive every day...


carpmart - 24/6/15 at 08:05 AM

quote:
Originally posted by jeffw
It is pretty 'ordinary' compared to the other options. If the choice was between that and the Audi RS6 or E Class AMG then maybe (although I'd take the RS6) but if you can get/run a GTR or an AM Vantage/Audi R8 then I'd do something else with my £50k


ordinary, are you sure?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rp8-Rv6cbdM


jeffw - 24/6/15 at 09:10 AM

Not my thing but if it is what you want, go for it, you don't need anyone on here to validate your choice.


carpmart - 24/6/15 at 09:16 AM

quote:
Originally posted by jeffw
Not my thing but if it is what you want, go for it, you don't need anyone on here to validate your choice.


Its sanity checking not validating I'm after really... LOL I just can't make my mind up as its a pretty subtle car, based on its performance...


sdh2903 - 24/6/15 at 09:20 AM

I don't think anyone is doubting the F10 m5 speed, for me anyway (I've only been lucky enough to passenger in a v10 m5 and F10 m5) in the words of James May, it just didn't have the "fizz". I found the v10 more exciting. And any car that plays synthetic engine noises through the speakers loses points for me!!


AntonUK - 24/6/15 at 09:44 AM

its not constructive to the conversation but personally I would love a GTR... me and the wife have promised ourselves one for her next daily. She isn't replacing her 335i until there is enough money in the pot to buy one. Cant wait... only another decade to go


jeffw - 24/6/15 at 09:46 AM

The acid test for me would be.....when you get out of it after a drive would you look back at it as you walk away.


02GF74 - 24/6/15 at 06:47 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Pojo
In my world a ..........This will be my last and only comment. Goodbye.


Why get the hump? Its a car forum and it was a car related question.

I wasnt quite aware of the money involved, i could but would not spend £ 50 k on a car but there is no reason somene else shoudnt. After all, it is then take take the xeoreciatuon hit so that the rest of us can buy 5-10 yr okd car for fraction of the price

Back on topic audi r8 or r10, or rs4.


mark chandler - 24/6/15 at 09:05 PM

V8 vantage with a manual box, you will be looking back but then I like Aston's


carpmart - 18/7/15 at 05:17 PM

To revist this thread, I went for a brand spanker F10 M5..... Just too good a deal and the car is absolutely epic. Sold the V10 M5, now waiting patiently for the delivery....


dilley - 18/7/15 at 10:04 PM

I've had most cars, including the ultimate gtr...pile of crap for the money! As a nice daily driver, I prefer diesel, loads of low down power. I thought Audi had an r8 diesel in the pipeline?


carpmart - 18/7/15 at 10:20 PM

quote:
Originally posted by dilley
I've had most cars, including the ultimate gtr...pile of crap for the money! As a nice daily driver, I prefer diesel, loads of low down power. I thought Audi had an r8 diesel in the pipeline?


The F10 M5, with a 4.4 V8 twin turbo, takes care of the low down grunt very nicely!