Board logo

Where to put the ECU?
sgraber - 19/9/03 at 03:35 AM

So! I'm finished tacking up the exhaust (turned out great - photos by tomorrow) and soon moving on to the wiring. I've decided to use the stock MR2 looms as there seem to be only a few pounds (Kg's) of extra wiring in there and I'm not up to the challenge of deconstructing the entire rats nest just to remove a few circuits. But maybe I'll do that some other year.

I do have to move the ECU from it's stock location because it's currently setting directly above the exhaust system. Question is, where should I put it? Inside the cockpit behind the passenger seat? or on the firewall in front of the transmission? Somewhere else in the car?

Alan, where will you be placing yours?

In regards to splicing the loom, would ye all recommend a wee bit o'solder or crimping?

(See, I can speak like a brit, even though I don't really know what the word 'Bollocks' means... )

Graber


Alan B - 19/9/03 at 04:09 AM

Easy Steve....

bollocks = testicles

ECU position.....erm....not sure yet...


kb58 - 19/9/03 at 05:23 AM

Easy, someplace out of the way, cool, and dry. I put mine behind the passenger seat.

For shortening the wires, solder and shrink wrap.


stephen_gusterson - 19/9/03 at 09:13 AM

I have a trademark on 'bolloxs' use it sparingly

ECU need to be ideally kept out of cold hot or wet areas, so inside the car would be preferable.

Electronics will only workbetween certain temperatures, and will malfunction if cooked or chilled.


atb

steve


tadltd - 19/9/03 at 09:41 AM

We had problems with ECU temp' on the first LMP - to the extent that it fried and needed replaced.

It was mainly due to being located in a hot spot in the engine bay. A bit of re-location, some heatshielding and venting of the engine bay took care of the problem.

But make sure you have plenty of engine bay venting if you're doing a mid-engine installation. It's not so much a problem when running, it's after a hard run, when the car's not moving and the all the heat's building up in the engine bay; that's what causes the problems. That's also the time when plastic connectors melt, so be careful where you place them!

Steve.


GO - 19/9/03 at 10:01 AM

The MR2 puts the ECU on the rear of the bulkhead behind the engine, i.e. in the boot. It gets pretty warm in there, but not hot.

I'm guessing you're not having a boot behind the engine tho so thats a non starter.

As you've not got a roof , I think behind the passenger seat is a bit risky, too open to rain, unless you can cover it well (see below for my plans...)

I'm also guessing that without massive mods to the wiring you're not going to have an awful lot of choice about how far away from the engine it can sit.

So, I think your best bet is going to be in the engine bay, but with decent heat sheilding.

I'm going to make an alu box for mine, leave a hole for the wires to poke out (obviously!) and seal up the edges with silicone, and mount with wires pointing down. That'll stop any water getting in, but you'll have to be careful of the heat still, I think I may have to put vent holes in the sides. At the moment I'm thinking of mounting it on the underside of the top of the passenger footwell.

Are you going to be using the engine fan off the MR2? There's a fan at the side of the engine bay that sucks in cold air through the side vent when it gets too hot (this actually causes another common problem on the MR2 - exhaust manifold cracking. The fan sits to the side of the engine and the cold air only hits one side of the manifold, so one side cools down while the other stays hot, crack! )

PS. have you got any more views of your design yet? Love the side view, wanna see the rest of it though!!!


kb58 - 19/9/03 at 03:13 PM

If it's put in the engine bay, consider a vented box. Cool air in at the bottom and hot air out the top.


sgraber - 19/9/03 at 03:24 PM

Thanks all. I think that I'll keep it in the engine bay, but route it under the fusebox that sits in the front lefthand corner of the engine bay. It looks like I'll have to add about 2 meters of length to the ECU wiring harness.

With regards to engine bay heat soak. I did intend to use the original fan in it's original location, but now that the manifold cracking was mentioned, and my cars manifold was cracked on #4 cylinder, I think I'll try to place it somewhere else.

I am building a complete Flat ali undertray for the engine bay and was simply intending on drilling a number of round 25mm holes in the ali (15 or so tightly spaced) just underneath the manifold area. The decklid will be vented and the rear will also have a large vent area. The side nacelles (sp) will also vent directly into the engine bay for cooling while moving. This is ARIZONA where it can be 120f in the shade!

How about if I attach the fan to the undertray directly over those vent holes so that it moves air up evenly over the exhaust and forces the air upwards out the decklid vents? With adequate care taken to waterproof the motor... It's a pretty compact fan. and moves a lot of air.

I haven't made any more progress on the body design. To busy replacing all the flooring in my house....

[Edited on 9/19/03 by sgraber]


kb58 - 19/9/03 at 05:40 PM

quote:
Originally posted by tadltd
We had problems with ECU temp' on the first LMP - to the extent that it fried and needed replaced.Steve.


I didn't realize you had built one before...


stephen_gusterson - 19/9/03 at 10:40 PM

the jag xj-s has the ECU in the boot - and the wires and vacuum pipe to the V12 run the whole length of the car....

!!!!


atb

steve


JoelP - 20/9/03 at 12:38 PM

consider a computer fan, like the one on a processor. That should help and you can mount it directly on the ECU.


Spyderman - 20/9/03 at 01:17 PM

If you isolated the exhaust from the engine bay with a heat shield, you could mount it at the rear of the engine bay.

Your idea for the fan sounds good. Might even give a little down force like the ducted F1 cars!

Terry


tadltd - 28/9/03 at 09:43 PM

The fan over the floor vents is a good idea - not only to pull in cool air (the excuse used on Gordon Murray's Brabham 'fan' car), but it will aid downforce quite considerably (which is why it was banned!! ).

You may want to use a mesh panel, though. That'll stop most of the larger pieces of road debri getting sucked into the engine bay!

Steve.


Spyderman - 28/9/03 at 11:03 PM

quote:
Originally posted by tadltd
The fan over the floor vents is a good idea - not only to pull in cool air (the excuse used on Gordon Murray's Brabham 'fan' car), but it will aid downforce quite considerably (which is why it was banned!! ).

Steve.

Erm!
Read my post above!

The fan is not that powerful or very large anyway!

[Edited on 28/9/03 by Spyderman]