Board logo

TIG welder. Your opinions.
JoelP - 8/11/05 at 10:10 PM

http://www.migtigarc.co.uk/TIG_/tig_.html

two welders on this page interest me, the Butters AC/DC 160 Tig and the SureWeld Suretig 180. The butters machine doesnt mention hf start, but surely it must at that price?

anyone have any experience of these machines, or opinions on them?

cheers.


James - 8/11/05 at 11:00 PM

Blimey!

Breaking all those Sierras must have paid better than I thought!

Would you be looking at the foot pedal as well? It really does make a massive difference to the control you get over the work.

I've done a bit of TIG (got my City and Guilds in it! ) and absoloutely love it... but not £1000's worth!


Sorry no helpful advice there- other than make sure you get a foot pedal!

Cheers,
James


Fozzie - 8/11/05 at 11:38 PM

Not had any experience of those 2 Joel, we have a Lincoln, which is brilliant (and a pedal with it)!
HTH Fozzie


Simon - 8/11/05 at 11:43 PM

Yep, we have a Lincoln too - great machine.

ATB

Simon


907 - 9/11/05 at 12:27 AM

Either of those two Joel sound good, although there may well be others.

On an AC/DC TIG, the HF needs to run all the time when set on A/C.
On some machines you can set it to On, Off, or Continuous.
On others when you switch to A/C the HF switches to continuous automatically.

The Butters has the best duty cycle but the Sure weld is the higher amp machine.

It is surprising how much current is needed for ally because it conducts heat so well. (Water cooled torch?)

I have a Sure Weld and it's been faultless, D/C only though. (Made the odd can or two)

I think you should buy either, and have it delivered to me so I can test it for a year or two.
Then I'll give you a proper analysis.


ATB

Paul G


colibriman - 9/11/05 at 11:25 AM

quote:

(Made the odd can or two)



and loads of folk think you should make one or 2 more..... me especially cos I need one !


dr-fastlane - 9/11/05 at 05:22 PM

"For those about to rock" take the Ac/dc......and get your car ready to ride on the "Highway to Hell"

:


big_wasa - 9/11/05 at 05:46 PM

quote:
Originally posted by colibriman
quote:

(Made the odd can or two)



and loads of folk think you should make one or 2 more..... me especially cos I need one !


Me to please........please.......


Peteff - 9/11/05 at 09:01 PM

The Suretig is a 400volt machine isn't it Joel? The Butters looks more portable.


JoelP - 9/11/05 at 09:46 PM

well spotted that pete. It says one phase 400v, surely a typo?

cheers for the input fellas. T'will be a few weeks til i decide, as i need a few productive weeks work to pay for it!

comments and suggestions still welcome