Board logo

should relays get hot?
andrew-theasby - 10/3/08 at 08:55 PM

As title really, i have a 306 hdi which, about 6 months ago, i smelt burning as i pulled into work. After investigating, i found the relay for the heater had melted on one side and stuck itself to the board. Managed to get it out but had to put another in to see what the problem was. When i did everything worked fine, but the relay got warm, so i unoplugged it. Left it unplugged for ages till i got chance for a better look. This one relay knocks out the air con, heater/cooler control, and also the fan speed (how does that work, its only one switch on its diagram???) Anyway, had to plug it back in one night cause i was in a storm and couldnt clear my window. After a while of blower on full, it wouldnt switch off or slow down, so unplugged it again. Assuming the relay had jammed i got home and plugged it back in again to see and everything worked fine, but nothing i did seemed to make it click so left it unplugged for another few weeks. Just plugged it back in again to start looking at it, and with the blower switched off for my 2 x half hour journeys, the hot cold control worked fine, and a/c light came on but i switched it off so all seems fine but the relay got warm straight away and stayed warm, but ive also noticed the same green relay thats next to it for elec windows also gets warm. None of the others do, but im worried its all going to catch fire after the first melted. Is this normal and the problems are just a coincedence, or is something causing a fault or two? Can anyone advise please?


r1_pete - 10/3/08 at 09:00 PM

relays shouldn't get that hot, is there any sign of arcing on the connections? The current round the actuator coil is very low, and shouldn't be enough to cause that amount of heat without blowing a fuse, so I'd suspect the problem is on the high current 'switched' circuit.


andrew-theasby - 10/3/08 at 09:47 PM

No, wouldnt really say there was any sign of arcing. The terminal where it melted is on the heavy circuit. What would cause it to draw extra current when the fan is off? Could something be slightly jamming the hot/cold air valve??? That must be in some way electrical (not like a slider on most cars) as it wont change from hot to cold without the relay in, but it does work fine when its in. Rescued attachment relay2.JPG
Rescued attachment relay2.JPG


PaulBuz - 10/3/08 at 10:11 PM

fit a new relay & carry out a load test with a meter if you can.
Obviously the current should be less than the relays rated current (20 or 30 A?)
The problem may just be a faulty old relay.
Once a bad connection forms within the relay, you create a hotspot which will only get worse & eventually burn out the relay.


andrew-theasby - 10/3/08 at 10:18 PM

That picture is of the first relay that melted. Since then i have been using a new relay, but the old one does actually still work. The one that was in when the blower jammed on full was the new one. What current should be going through it when the blower is off? Without it, nothing works. At first i assumed the relay would just be to switch the blower on and off, but obviousy it isnt. And the one next to it gets warm too. I will try and measure it tho
Just thought, not sure well have a DC ameter that will carry that kind of load, so probably cant do that

[Edited on 10/3/08 by andrew-theasby]


omega 24 v6 - 10/3/08 at 10:33 PM

Looks like a possible bad/poor connection INSIDE the relay.Possibly a dry solder joint or a damaged/broken track.

Also it looks like an ign controlled relay (unless it's a trick of the camers then the power circuit terminal look to be bigger than the std 6.5mm ones. So it could in theory be rated to as much as 100amps.

[Edited on 10/3/08 by omega 24 v6]


andrew-theasby - 10/3/08 at 10:48 PM

Its rated 25 amps, just the same as the one next to it, just a standard 4x 6.5mm pin relay. The old one got really hot, the new one gets hot, and the one next to it gets hot. Wouldnt that point to something other than a faulty relay? (Dont know what btw, just thinking out loud)


omega 24 v6 - 10/3/08 at 11:05 PM

The relays WILL get hot to an extent. Don't know in degrees I'm afraid sorry. You could try a lazer thermometer at it though if your really worried. I'd imagine not more or round about 40 th 50 degrees C. You should be able to touch/hold it without burning yourself. Also if the relay is fused and the fuse is of the correct raing and does not blow then I'd suspect the first(burnt) relay to be fubbared.


andrew-theasby - 10/3/08 at 11:41 PM

Thats pretty much what i thought, until the fan stuck on with the new relay in. Cant explain that one. You can still have a fire with less than 20amps. They are definitely hot rather than warm, but theres no others of that size to compare with, none of the others get warm at all. Ill try running the blower a bit tomorrow and see if it gets any warmer, and progresively try more. Until then im carrying a fire extinguisher Thanks

[Edited on 10/3/08 by andrew-theasby]


dhutch - 10/3/08 at 11:45 PM

Interesting.
- I spend two hours the weekend before last chisaling the remains of the rearheatedscreen relay of my new 306 off the holder.
- Ive never had any problems with the prevous 306 in the 7 years we had that, and since i replaced the relay (with a second hand one, from said pervous 306) ive had no problems.

Deffonatly sounds like dodgy relay to me.
- They do get warm if there on a long time, but it should only be warm, burning is always a bad thing in electrical parts imo.


Daniel


MikeRJ - 10/3/08 at 11:55 PM

Every melted relay or fuse I have ever seen (mostly on French cars) has been caused by a poor connection between the high current wiring and the relay, often the crimp on the connector is the culprit. This can put a lot of heat through the affected terminal into the relay.


RazMan - 11/3/08 at 11:32 AM

I had a similar experience with a fuse box which had a very slightly loose fitting fuse on a headlamp circuit - the small resistance caused some heat which actually melted the fuse box


andrew-theasby - 11/3/08 at 12:19 PM

Thanks, that sounds like whats happening then, maybe the other one is about to do the same too