Board logo

Need Help diagnosing this problem (tin top)
bigbravedave - 15/2/11 at 09:29 AM

I got this message from SWIMBO this morning, she drives a 52 plate mk6 fiesta, that had the faintest drumming from a lh corner a couple of weeks ago:

“My car has definitely got worse, when I set off this morning it sounded all clunky like something was loose and moving about and then once I got going it kinda sounded like when you spin a coin on a desk and its going round and round before it comes to a stop. It was doing that when I was going slow and fast, just speeding up or down in relation to what I was doing and when I went round a couple of roundabouts it was quite clunky”

Im planning on getting some parts at lunchtime and fitting them tonight, what do we rekon it could be outer CV joint or a wheel bearing?

Many thanks in advance


britishtrident - 15/2/11 at 09:33 AM

Loose wheel ?


tony-devon - 15/2/11 at 09:45 AM

wheel bearing I reckon

depending on how bad its gone, also check the ABS sensor, mine went big time and rubbed the sensor, about 2 weeks after the bearing went, the car played up going into traction control and the ABS cuttign in every time you braked


britishtrident - 15/2/11 at 10:01 AM

Once you have heard a loose wheel you recognise it instantly ---- fits the description exactly.


nib1980 - 15/2/11 at 10:01 AM

loose wheel


mcerd1 - 15/2/11 at 10:14 AM

^^ tell her to check all the wheel nuts are tight before driving it home

not long ago someone I know got overtaken by there own wheel on the motorway


kj - 15/2/11 at 10:20 AM

This may sound daft but, does it have wheel trims as it could just be dirt behind them or part of the inner trim damaged.


mrwibble - 15/2/11 at 10:24 AM

if not above, egg shaped tyre?


tony-devon - 15/2/11 at 10:27 AM

never had a loose wheel so I bow to your experience on this matter

have you had tyres fitted recently? or maybe someone been trying to nick them?

a loose wheel is certainly more worrying than a bearing

but on the other hand its far cheaper


bigbravedave - 15/2/11 at 12:58 PM

after the loose wheel comment, I phoned the AA who sent a van to check the nuts (as she's stuck in meetings all day)

Ironicly I know the driver as he's my local garage In his own words the rear right wheel bearing is "paggered" like an inch of play top and bottom and he's dropping it on my driveway shortly (very nice man)

I've got the bits to swap it tonight,

Few, cheers for the help guys mystry solved!


mcerd1 - 15/2/11 at 02:07 PM

quote:
Originally posted by bigbravedaveIronicly I know the driver as he's my local garage In his own words the rear right wheel bearing is "paggered" like an inch of play top and bottom

scary

I don't think I've ever seen one that bad


bigbravedave - 15/2/11 at 10:05 PM

Cheers guys, all sorted was a completely failed rear wheel bearing, the cage that holds the needle rollers had failed hence alot of play. it went from very light druming to complete failure in 100miles!

I splashed out £18 on a new drum and pressed the bearing in at work, so it was a wheel off and one nut job once home in the rain.