Board logo

Recommend me a good commuter bike...
Steve Hignett - 4/3/10 at 09:26 PM

Hi All,

I am in the relatively unfortunate position where I lost my job at the start of the year and my wife is due to give birth to our first child in approx 3 weeks time.

I am currently working at a manufacturing firm that most have heard of, but it is on a hugely reduced salary and travelling an awful lot further than I used too...

We have already decided to go down from two cars to one (mine is a Seat Leon Cupra 2001, and the wife's a Rover 220TD) Although it makes more sense to keep the Rover due to fuel economy, it's not that great a car, and the Leon is obv not that great for economy, but apart from needing £300 spending on it after the weekends MOT (which I don't have) it's an ok car!

I also have a Yr2000 Yamaha R6 in Virgin Mobile colours, that I intend to sell when the weather picks up. It's in need of an MOT and a back tyre (also don't really have the money for that!). But this evening I realised that I could make a smaller change and still come out OKish...

I could sell the Rover, keep the Leon, and sell the R6 to purchase a commuter bike...

So, which bike to go for?
I estimate the R6 value at somewhere between £1600 and £1850 ish, so take out £150 for the tyre and the MOT and I would like to get a bike for circa £1500.

I know the Bandit, Hornet are the right shape for commuter bikes, but does anyone have any real experience of any commuter bikes? I need to do approx 70 miles per day, and the roads are M6, then A500, then A50, A520, B5040...

All suggestions welcome!
ebay, would prob be my method of purchase...

Cheers,
Steve


Wheels244 - 4/3/10 at 09:32 PM

Keep the R6.
Not bad on fuel.
Well capable bike and arrive at work with smile on your face.
Whatever you change it for would probably need something replacing on it sooner or later.
Better the devil you know sometimes.

[Edited on 4/3/10 by Wheels244]


55ant - 4/3/10 at 09:38 PM

thought you were talking bicycle!


Andy S - 4/3/10 at 09:45 PM

Google 500cc Commuters and follow the MCN link

GPz would be my choice as a decent enough compromise - ER or CB for Captain sensible

Being an old fart I have an XS650 and Daytona 955i

Andrew


rayward - 4/3/10 at 09:48 PM

i commuted on a GPZ500 for about 2 years, (even having my tools strapped on the back whe i was contracting !)

ideal for the job

hth

Ray


whitestu - 4/3/10 at 09:51 PM

I had a GPZ as well. They are dead solid and cheap to run.
Not sure I'd want to commute 70 miles on a bike though.

Stu


Steve Hignett - 4/3/10 at 09:56 PM

Am looking at suggestions as made so far, but just to clarify one point it's 35miles each way

ETA;- ps, If I spend £1500 on something I don't want to spend a penny on it afterwards! Also, soes anyone have a preference for which all weather tyres? (I've been running part worn race tyres for the last 5 years on all my bikes )

[Edited on 4/3/10 by Steve Hignett]


flibble - 4/3/10 at 09:58 PM

Did 40 miles each way on a TDM850 for a few years come rain or snow, loved it, easily get one for £1500 now.


big_wasa - 4/3/10 at 10:05 PM

Yep had three Gpz500s. Good for what they are.

You may aswell keep the r6.


Steve Hignett - 4/3/10 at 10:14 PM

Assuming I keep the R6, which I don't fancy for the simple fact that I have a serious back problem and it's not the best riding position for that sort of thing!, what tyres can I really depend on for all year round grippy riding???


daviep - 4/3/10 at 10:18 PM

ZZR1100, comfortable, scary fast and you can use it as a donor in a couple of years when you're back on your feet

EDITED FOR POOR GRAMMAR

[Edited on 4/3/10 by daviep]


mads - 4/3/10 at 10:22 PM

highly recommend the bandit. done over 250 miles in a day on many an occasion with no problems, and sometimes two up with a full panniers set on.

it's a good all round bike and if you can get the S version, its semi-faired so fine for the motorway too. you should be able to pick up a decent one for £1500 and they are easy to work on. I took mine almost completely apart when i had an off and that was with no mechanical knowledge. even replaced the chain and sprocket on it.


flipp - 4/3/10 at 10:58 PM

have a look at a yamaha 900 diversion a bit bland but reliable, cheap parts an shaft drive so minimal maintainance


mookaloid - 4/3/10 at 11:26 PM

Probably get shot down and I hesitate to say it but a Honda Deauville is a great commuter. Weather protection, built in luggage capability, built for comfort and should be economical.


Memphis Twin - 5/3/10 at 01:09 AM

BMW k75s or K75RT. Great triple engine;shaft drive; weather protection; comfortable riding position; lovely exhaust note;BMW build quality and reliability.

Or a BMW flat twin....like mine

[Edited on 5/3/10 by Memphis Twin]


welderman - 5/3/10 at 08:16 AM

Why not put some some renthal bars on the R6, street fighter styleee, goos seating position for your back to mate, i will do it for you.




street fighter
street fighter


[Edited on 5/3/10 by welderman]


afj - 5/3/10 at 08:29 AM

er5 or cb500 would i had a gpz500 for 2 years and was great 0-60 faster than most cars and 125mph and 55mpg
can you cope with 55mph then get a honda cb125 you might crack 90mpg


sebastiaan - 5/3/10 at 09:10 AM

quote:
Originally posted by mookaloid
Probably get shot down and I hesitate to say it but a Honda Deauville is a great commuter. Weather protection, built in luggage capability, built for comfort and should be economical.




I was actually thinking Honda PC800... Not the prettiest thing in the world though.


Dangle_kt - 5/3/10 at 09:41 AM

Hi Steve,

SV650s ticks most the boxes, but the seating position isn't the best.

Bandit 600s would be a good choice, but I would suggest considering a shaft driven bike.

£100 for new chain and sprockets a few months in is a bit of a kick in the knackers - plus it cuts down on the maintenance - I cant imagine cleaning and oiling the chain will be high on your list when you have done a full days work, ridden 70 miles AND have a wife and baby to look after.

So, you could consider a Deaville - they do exactly what you are after - but no more, they aint fun and they aint sexy. St1100 might just scrape into your price range too, but it might need some love at that price which isn't what you want.

I commuted for 3 years on a cbr400rr tri-arm, great little bike - bulletproof mechanically, but cramped riding position.

I commuted to nearly 1.5 years on a sv650s, great engine, crap brakes, bit cramped.

I commuted on a GPZ500 for a few months - didnt like it at all, did the job but felt like it was made from cheap everything.

Commuted on a bandit 600s, very comfy, great at motorway speeds, and excelent low speed handling for cutting through the traffic.

Also you could consider a susuki gs500e, good solid bikes, but I have never ridden one - just know they are known for being good solid commuters.

As is the Honda Bros, but it might be an ex courier...

If I was you I'd be looking at a faired bike, a naked will give you a sore neck on that length commute - even if your neck is bigger than my waist!

[Edited on 5/3/10 by Dangle_kt]


fesycresy - 5/3/10 at 11:09 AM

Economical, faired, bullet proof, cheap spares, cheap insurance and it's red (just like Virgin colours).......

This is the bike for you my son




thunderace - 5/3/10 at 11:29 AM

try to find a thunderace best all rounder i have ever owned.o
a thundercat if you want a 600cc.


mads - 5/3/10 at 02:09 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Dangle_kt
I cant imagine cleaning and oiling the chain will be high on your list when you have done a full days work, ridden 70 miles AND have a wife and baby to look after.



ah the joys of a scottoiler....!

as for cleaning, yep it is a PITA but if you clean the bike regularly enough the chain can be done at same time.