Board logo

it is true, MOTs are ...
02GF74 - 16/2/09 at 09:36 AM

.... not worth the paper they are printed on.

No, really.

All the MOT is is a statement that at the time of testing the vehicle met certain criteria.

For example, Land Rover got MOT on Friday - woo hoo!!!
Then on the way back from work, the front offside indicator decided to take a rest from flashing!!! It is not exactly hard work is it?!

Anyway, refitting same bulb sorted but it does go to show.


Mr Whippy - 16/2/09 at 09:39 AM

Seeing it’s a landy you were lucky nothing else broke or fell off


paul the 6th - 16/2/09 at 09:42 AM

There's probably a more reliable/efficient system but it does it's job in keeping dangerous cars off the road (most of the time anyway)


scootz - 16/2/09 at 09:44 AM

Alternative?


nick205 - 16/2/09 at 09:45 AM

Gives the snoopers one more chance to check everything else is in order (Tax/Insurance etc.) Also keeps a whole army of people working in Swansea and around the country testing the vehicles.


Mr Whippy - 16/2/09 at 09:49 AM

wtf...there seems to be some avatar piracy going about!

missing the girl with the long legs then...???

[Edited on 16/2/09 by Mr Whippy]


jollygreengiant - 16/2/09 at 09:53 AM

quote:
Originally posted by nick205
Gives the snoopers one more chance to check everything else is in order (Tax/Insurance etc.) Also keeps a whole army of people working in Swansea and around the country testing the vehicles.


Correct.

The MOT is basically only valid for the time at which it was printed, however certain items are expected to last and be valid for a few months at least. To whit Vehicle structure. but basically it is like you said Valid until its driven away from the station.


r1_pete - 16/2/09 at 09:53 AM

I'm with Scootz, whats a viable alternative?

The MOT does look for things like excessive wear, which in the testers view are likely to fail - his veiw should be common across all testers they do work to a set of standards and are trained and qualified for the job.

I think a valid MOT is an indication the vehicle is structurally sound, and will do all af the required functions safely and effectively.

Bulbs and connections etc. can fail at any time, hence when you took your driving test you were asked questions about your pre journey checks....


r1_pete - 16/2/09 at 09:55 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Mr Whippy
wtf...there seems to be some avatar piracy going about!

missing the girl with the long legs then...???

[Edited on 16/2/09 by Mr Whippy]


Would seem the Falcon has a cult following........


jlparsons - 16/2/09 at 10:08 AM

My brother t-reg clio passed mot when the dashboard was completely disconnected!!


Peteff - 16/2/09 at 10:47 AM

You can get take a car for an mot a month before it's due date and get 13 months mot for 1 year as well.


UncleFista - 16/2/09 at 10:48 AM

In the IOM there are no MOT tests of any type, but if you crash and it's deemed to be down to an unsafe vehicle, you're in trouble...

Having said that, there's loads of old "classics" on the road over there, most with no sills etc.


wicket - 16/2/09 at 11:03 AM

quote:


All the MOT is is a statement that at the time of testing the vehicle met certain criteria.




I think it says the same on the SVA MAC


pewe - 16/2/09 at 11:51 AM

Worst case was Swmbo's car which failed for a side-light bulb - loose connection.
Whilst sorting that one out for a re-test noticed one of the front flexi-pipes had a huge blister in it - no comment on that by the tester and basically VOSA didn't want to know "test is only valid whilst vehicle is on the tester's premises" i.e it happened on the way home - not!
Cheers, Pewe


mcerd1 - 16/2/09 at 12:14 PM

it can be a bit of a pain sometimes but on the whole I don't mind the MOT

I try and keep my cars in good working condition all the time anyway, so I've only ever had minor things at the MOT


but on the other hand a mate of mine just had his MOT'd (he knows nothing about cars) and had a long list of things including 2 bald tyres, one wrong sized wheel
if it hadn't been for the MOT he'd have never known (and he works for the police!)


actually now I think about it I'm a bit worried about the new tin-tops test (in a couple of months) - I've never had a car with EFI or CAT before.....

[Edited on 16/2/09 by mcerd1]


MikeR - 16/2/09 at 12:36 PM

its a lot better than some places. I've heard of places where you only MOT the car when you sell it or others where you don't bother full stop.

What would you replace it with? Weekly inspections?


02GF74 - 16/2/09 at 12:54 PM

quote:
Originally posted by MikeR


What would you replace it with? Weekly inspections?


I would have it so that every car tow a trailer with a little man or woman inside it who hops outwhen the vehicle is stationary to check tyres, suspension, lights and steering.

The trialer will have a roof tent so the wee person can live in there.

This will not only remove the homeless of the strees, reduce the unemploymenbt rate as well as car crime as every car will have its own guard.


Mr Whippy - 16/2/09 at 01:04 PM

quote:
Originally posted by 02GF74
quote:
Originally posted by MikeR


What would you replace it with? Weekly inspections?


I would have it so that every car tow a trailer with a little man or woman inside it who hops outwhen the vehicle is stationary to check tyres, suspension, lights and steering.

The trialer will have a roof tent so the wee person can live in there.

This will not only remove the homeless of the strees, reduce the unemploymenbt rate as well as car crime as every car will have its own guard.


soooooo....what have you been dinking today...a bottle of buckfast??