Board logo

Which Baby Car Seat?
Guinness - 9/4/09 at 05:15 PM

Any new parents in?

Does anyone subscribe to which? or know which are the best baby car seats?

Halfords have a half price sale on this weekend, so was hoping to pick up one this weekend.

I know we don't need it for another 4 months, but where there is the chance to get a decent seat at a reasonable price.

Cheers

Mike


Danozeman - 9/4/09 at 05:18 PM

We found it best to get a pushchair with a carrier with it. Then you can lift it from the car and clip it onto the pushchair without having to disturb the baby. Most of them rock etc.


bob tatt - 9/4/09 at 06:04 PM

check out the recaro ones ive got two one for new borns and one for 12 month to seven years. really good seats not the cheapest but very good value in my opinion. if its good enough for the racers is good enough for my little man and the other one due on monday. they also do travel systems, which we bought first time round. although to be honest the travel system was not great. and as a bonus all the lads think its well cool having the little ones in recaro from birth, you will like cars and engines not bloody cricket.


spdpug98 - 9/4/09 at 06:28 PM

We have the Recaro Young Sport which is a great bit of kit


Hammerhead - 9/4/09 at 06:34 PM

recaro don't brush up well in the tests. We have a which? subscription and it recommended the maxi cosi cabrio with isofix base. The maxi cosi cabrio can attach to quite a few prams/pushchairs so as already said, you wont need to disturb the baby.

http://www.maxi-cosi.com/maxicosi/productindex.aspx?id=14&language=gb-en

Hope that helps.
Steve.

[Edited on 9/4/09 by Hammerhead]


Ben_Copeland - 9/4/09 at 06:35 PM

Hows that "which" one cough....


Maxi Cosi Cabriofix (with Easyfix base)

Front crash: 5 stars
Side crash: 4 stars
Overall safety: 5 stars
Fitting in car: 5 stars
82% Best buy

Britax BABY-SAFE plus (Isofix)

Front crash: 5 stars
Side crash: 4 stars
Overall safety: 5 stars
Fitting in car: 5 stars
81% Best buy

Mothercare Meteor (with base)

Front crash: 5 stars
Side crash: 4 stars
Overall safety: 5 stars
Fitting in car: 5 stars
79% Best buy


Ben_Copeland - 9/4/09 at 06:37 PM

Theres more if you need them, but thats the top 3 on review.

If you have a model in mind, let me know and i'll look it up on Which?


balidey - 9/4/09 at 06:53 PM

if your car has isofix points then definitly go for one with a permanent base that you drop the seat onto.

We had the maxi cosi with easybase, then changed car and got the same with the isofix base.

And ANY shop worth their salt selling car seats should NOT sell you one without fitting it in your car and advising if its suitable.


JoelP - 9/4/09 at 07:47 PM

we got a mamas and papas skate pram with the primo viaggio car seat, does the trick but surey over priced. If i had to do it again id get second hand off ebay, but the missus wouldnt stand for it!


sminney - 9/4/09 at 08:32 PM

its worth checking with the local council, with mine, they have a fitting service and you take your car to them and they recommend a seat that fits the car correctly & show you how to fit it, and then you go and buy it from wherever you can find it cheapest.


Agriv8 - 9/4/09 at 08:41 PM

I would easilly recomend Maxi Cosi Cabrio fix with easy base or iso base ( if your car has iso. ) always come very close to the top of the which list and we had no problems with ours.

you can get mounting system so they clip to prams ours clipped into our Quinny Buzz.

If you want to do a good comparison of travel systems go to Toys r us ( most include a babies r us ) you can see most of them side by side and the staff were really helpful rather than Mothercare that could not give a SHITE apart from geting your cash.

regards

Agriv8


pif - 9/4/09 at 09:56 PM

if you go to a shop ask if the fitters - always ask to get it fitted in your car - are gold fitters. they are the best and prob better qualified than your council / rospa checkers.
guarantee the baby fits the seat but no guarantee the seat fits the car.

would recco from experience one that fits with your buggy / pram.

priori xp or priori iso if you have iso fixings are excellent seats.

hth
pif


Marcus - 11/4/09 at 01:02 PM

As Agriv8, we used exactly the same system for 9 months with no issues (and 2 cars). The seat was very versatile attaching to our Quinny very easily.
Whilst your sprog is small enough try to get a proper carry cot rather than using the seat all the time though.