Board logo

Buying a rover 75 diesel with no service history
paulf - 29/7/09 at 07:49 AM

Im looking to change my tin top and fancy a rover 75.I looked at an 02 plate tourer with 135000 miles but no service history although it is up at £1990 so cheap, it is being sold by a local dealer that moves on main dealer PXs.
On asking about the service history he said there is none but it has been HPI checked etc.It drives well and im tempted by it but worried by the lack of history, main concern is the items like clutch and turbo most other things i think could be sorted reasonably easily bearing in mind i never take my cars to a garage apart from for an MOT would this be possible with a newer more complicated car?
My other option is to just get another cheap ie sub £1000 rover 600 or a 25 or 45 diesel and save some more for a newer 75 with history.
Any suggestions?
Paul


smart51 - 29/7/09 at 07:53 AM

Make sure you get all the keys. New ones are only available through BMW as the key code is stored on a BMW server in Germany. I'm guessing it is big money to add new keys.

I know a few people who really like 75s and the BMW diesel engine is popular too.


Mr Whippy - 29/7/09 at 07:57 AM

that seems very expensive tbh

I paid £1600 for a 50k mint 6 year old Almera with full Nissan service history for missy just a few weeks ago.

With a Diesel I'd be concerned about the fuel pump going at the mileage, one of the guys at work recently scrapped his 407 due to the cost of replacing it


nick205 - 29/7/09 at 08:14 AM

Is it a case of the history being lost or just not existing?

If you know where it came from you might be able to check some history - i.e. did a local garage service it at some point?

Also, any particular reason for the Rover fascination? Not knocking the them, but there are lots of other cheap and reliable cars out there.


paulf - 29/7/09 at 08:31 AM

Im not sure if the history has been genuinly lost or conveniently lost, It does seem they have some fuel pump problems ive just been reading the rover forum and the in tank pumps seem a problem.
I have considered other makes, but have had a 600 diesel for the last 7 years and it has been a very good car and Rover trim and equipment levels seem to be better than fords or vauxhalls etc. I have thought of looking at Bmw, or Vw passats etc but not had any experience of them.Definitely want a diesel as nowadays cant seee much point in a thirsty petrol tin top.


paulf - 29/7/09 at 08:33 AM

How many keys should it have? is there as red master key like the older models?
Paul.

quote:
Originally posted by smart51
Make sure you get all the keys. New ones are only available through BMW as the key code is stored on a BMW server in Germany. I'm guessing it is big money to add new keys.

I know a few people who really like 75s and the BMW diesel engine is popular too.


britishtrident - 29/7/09 at 08:36 AM

I have heard of one 75 diesel that did alomost 3 times that mileage before the taxi driver owner traded it in for another.


The variant of bmw engine is slightly diffrent from that used by BMW and Land-Rover --- the Rover engine has fixed turbo vanes which make it more reliable.
At 2002 it could still have the 115hp version the engine rather than the 131bp ---- only difference is software.

The engine compartment fuel pump can fail but it is rare, I am not sure of the cost --- you can check the Rimmer Brothers web site. A more common loss of fuel pressure on pre-204 cars was the in tank fuel filler falling apart but modst cars will have been modified by now.

Apart from the usual MAS sensor these engines just don't go wrong --- they just don't, I have heard of a couple of crank or cam sensor failures and one engine with leaking injectors but that is is all.


Keys cost 150pounds each this will let you unlock and drive the car however if you want the key programmed to the remote locking add 40 to 60 pounds.

If it is an automatic walk away from it --- Rover used the same JATCO gearbox used by Jaguar, Toyota, Ford and Nissan ----- although it seems to give less trouble in the 75 basically it is not reliable over 80,000 miles.

The manual gearbox is the Getrag 5 speed also used by many other manufacturers, I have never heard of one failling apart from 1 car with broken gearchange cable.
I would look for evidence the clutch has been changed, the clutch is a very expensive item to replace usually involves new hydraulics and a new dual mass flywheel.

Chaissis wise the the diesel is more prone to broken springs than the lighter engined cars. Springs can be found for about 40 pounds each

Body wise the door locks are the only known issue ---- check the central locking workks --- 1 push of the blipper unlocks the drivers dor only 2 pushes the rest of the doors (but deallers can alter in software). The Door lock mechanism is quite delicate and it is quite common to find the drivers door won't remote unlock --- cost 100 quid for new part or 25 to 40 off ebay.


No major replacements are on the service scheduled for the diesel --- oil change interval is 15,000 miles oil should be fully synthertic ---- looks for signs of frequent changes.

Brakes wise the only problem is they all have lousy hand brakes ---- must be done using official BMW-Rover method and has to be adjusted inside the rear disc-drum which usually entails removing the disc-drum unit.

Tyre wear on both outside edges is normal on these cars --- less of problem on cars with 15" wheels.


Of course you could look for a low mileage petrol 75 and convert to LPG ---depending on your distance from a cheap lpg ststion should be a lot cheaper to run the diesel.

[Edited on 29/7/09 by britishtrident]


Volvorsport - 29/7/09 at 08:50 AM

i wouldnt pay £1900 .

they do have fuel pump issues , and if the clutch goes - its dual mass - so you might aswell replace that at the same time at a cost i can imagine is over £500 .

if theres no service history , walk away .


britishtrident - 29/7/09 at 11:48 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Volvorsport
i wouldnt pay £1900 .

they do have fuel pump issues , and if the clutch goes - its dual mass - so you might aswell replace that at the same time at a cost i can imagine is over £500 .

if theres no service history , walk away .


Engine bay pump issues are not unknown but not that common either ---- perhaps only 1 in 40 cars are effected.
Loads of second hand spares for 75s on ebay thesedays, buying a cheap one and breaking and selling every single bit off on ebay can yeild very big profits.

If it were me buying clutch wear is more of worry --- dual mass flywheels and the hydraulics can add greatly to the cost of what isn't the easiest clutch to change.


britishtrident - 29/7/09 at 12:07 PM

quote:
Originally posted by paulf
Im not sure if the history has been genuinly lost or conveniently lost, It does seem they have some fuel pump problems ive just been reading the rover forum and the in tank pumps seem a problem.
I have considered other makes, but have had a 600 diesel for the last 7 years and it has been a very good car and Rover trim and equipment levels seem to be better than fords or vauxhalls etc. I have thought of looking at Bmw, or Vw passats etc but not had any experience of them.Definitely want a diesel as nowadays cant seee much point in a thirsty petrol tin top.


The 75 & ZT are very different from standard Euro-Jap tin and very different from the 600 and other Rovers , in truth the 75 is a fwd BMW.

The 75 is 20% Rover 80% BMW
The 25 is 90% rover, 10% Honda
The 45 is 20% Rover 80% Honda
The 600 were almost enirely Honda although the diesel had a Rover power train
The 820 was 40% Rover 60% Honda

My 75 puts a smile on my face every time I drive it -- for sure it is more than a little too heavy for its 1.8 engine but it corners wonderfully and feels solid.

I ran a Rover 623 for just short of 4 years --- it was quite fastish, 100% reliable but of all the cars I have owned probably the most boring car to drive.

The Rover 25 is a great car to drive with the K series engine --- really fun but with a heavy diesel up front it would be a different matter,

The 45 is really a botched Honda that was forced on Rover it handles and goes well with the K series and is more suited to the diesel than the 25. Most models have a decent level of option but the interior and exterior look awful. Some body spares are hard to find for the 45.

Cheap 800 very low mileage used to be easy to find at auction for 500 quid but most will have fallen foul of the dreaded scrapage scheme.




[Edited on 29/7/09 by britishtrident]


JonBowden - 6/8/09 at 10:04 PM

I've just bought a 47k 75 CDT tourer and I love it.
It cost me £3500 and has no significant faults
I don't doubt that there will be some expenses over the next few years.
If I sell it in a few years, it will still be a low mileage car. My worry about buying a high mileage car is that when you sell it it will be a mega-mileage car and worth little.


paulf - 7/8/09 at 09:50 PM

Decided to give this one a miss , i have been looking on autotrader and it seems theres plenty about at good prices.Im not to worried about resale value as I tend to buy cars and run them till there on there last legs.My present car is a 600 diesel with 238000 on the clock, it had about 170,000 and almost full service history when i bought it 7 or 8 years ago , so im going to look for a car with high trim level ie leather etc and good service history but be prepared to accept a higher mileage to get a well maintained example.There seems to be a lot about with limited or no service history .
Paul

quote:
Originally posted by JonBowden
I've just bought a 47k 75 CDT tourer and I love it.
It cost me £3500 and has no significant faults
I don't doubt that there will be some expenses over the next few years.
If I sell it in a few years, it will still be a low mileage car. My worry about buying a high mileage car is that when you sell it it will be a mega-mileage car and worth little.


paulf - 24/8/09 at 04:52 PM

Just got carried away on Ebay and bid on and won a 1999 75 diesel Connesier with leather and all extras for £670 the only thing is its done 218000 so not sure if im going to regret it or not.I suppose I can always trade it in or put it back on E Bay or brake it for spares. Going to have a look and arrange when i can collect it later.
Paul


MikeRJ - 24/8/09 at 04:59 PM

quote:
Originally posted by britishtrident
Apart from the usual MAS sensor these engines just don't go wrong --- they just don't,


I thought the injectors on these were fairly prone to failure? They certainly aren't the most robust items on the BMWs.