Board logo

Choice of car for female friend
Jumpy Guy - 12/7/06 at 11:07 AM

okay, one of my mates needs to buy a car, and is looking at her local auction.
Which would you buy?
all roughly the same money (ish)......

or another suggestion-
20 K per year, single female, for work, cheapish, minimal effort...


mookaloid - 12/7/06 at 11:17 AM

When I was in the motor trade, I always recommended japanese cars to friends.

This is because they are generally more reliable.

There is nothing worse than recommending a car to someone which then breaks down........

so out of the above, probably the Avensis although they are built in the UK

Cheers

Mark


greggors84 - 12/7/06 at 11:19 AM

quote:

or another suggestion-
20 K per year, single female, for work, cheapish, minimal effort...


Is that your lonely hearts advert for her?

Sorry i couldnt be more help!


omega 24 v6 - 12/7/06 at 11:29 AM

I voted 406. Any of them will do prolly your eyes your merchant and all that.
As an asides none of them have rear wheel drive but no tranny tunnel makes it easier to get your leg over


spunky - 12/7/06 at 11:31 AM

quote:
Originally posted by greggors84
quote:

or another suggestion-
20 K per year, single female, for work, cheapish, minimal effort...


Is that your lonely hearts advert for her?

Sorry i couldnt be more help!


LOL

I know naff all about regular cars and tend to run about in jalopies and throw them away at first sign of trouble.

But IMVHO

Xzara - no, its French
Focus - well, ok I guess. Its a Focus
Mondeo - not a lot of style there for single female really!
Pug - No, its French
Toyota - gets my vote, simply because I have a Surf.

I'm not a lot of help either.

Have you considered leasing, for less money she could have a new MIni, MX5 for a couple of years. They even send you the tax in the post.

John

[Edited on 12/7/06 by spunky]


tks - 12/7/06 at 11:32 AM

diesel cars are far more reliabel then petrol ones.

Would get the HDI one.

Offcourse you should do a check of what you buy first.

also it will depend on if you buy from a owner of from a garage.

the garage would give you waranty??

the other not..

Tks

wy not look for a toyota corrolla diesel?

or a vauxhall astra diesel?


DaveFJ - 12/7/06 at 11:32 AM

You seemed to emphasize the reliablility.... no question it HAS to be japanese...... yup it's a boring car but so what! it will run forever unlike the a ford or any french cr*p!


britishtrident - 12/7/06 at 11:36 AM

Toyota or Honda or ugh hate to say it Nissan, the Almera may haze zero personality but is actually very good.


DaveFJ - 12/7/06 at 11:42 AM

I'm guessing the budget is 3-4k ? In which case there would be no question for me...

Mitsubishi Galant. Damn fine car, good looking and they NEVER go wrong. Just wish I had never got rid of mine


Howlor - 12/7/06 at 11:53 AM

To be honest I would be inclined to look at a 1.9TD Seat Leon. Full Audi A3 interior, proven reliable engine, 50+ mpg, easy to drive, good vision, comfortable with large car feel etc and all the bells and whistles with them.

My wife has a 1.4 and absolutely loves the thing. I drive it now and again and it really is a good car for the money.

Steve


Jumpy Guy - 12/7/06 at 12:00 PM

Numbers dont add up!!!

Three recomendations for the Avensis, but only two votes!!

Who didnt vote? eh? eh?

I'll find out......


caber - 12/7/06 at 12:01 PM

NO NO! suggest something that will make a good donor Mazda MX5 for example then you can buy the salvage when she wraps it round a tree!
Caber


nib1980 - 12/7/06 at 12:08 PM

Nissan Micra, new ones are stylish (for girls) and cheap, realiable as you like and the new 160sr is fairly peppy too.

just a thought


nick205 - 12/7/06 at 12:15 PM

Of the choices you give the Focus gets my vote for all round ease of ownership.

As per Howlor's comment above, I too would consider the Leon TDI for the same reasons. I've run one for a while and am considering another when the time comes.

Nick


Tricky Dave - 12/7/06 at 12:25 PM

I've got a leon - it's great. It is a cupra though, which helps.

My girlfriend is after a nissan figaro - bit out of the ordinary, cool (for girls!) and micra underpinnings so jap reliability. Only problem is the price, considering how old they are.

Other recomendation would be a yaris - the GFs current car. Cheap as chips, never skips a beat, still look quite funky. Would get a bigger engine than the 1.0 she's got though.


yorkshire-engines - 12/7/06 at 01:43 PM

any idea,s what the girly is saying on DAVE FJ ,S picture ???????


ned - 12/7/06 at 01:59 PM

focus or 406 from the list for cheapness of running, pug for good economy. I would have to agree with those suggesting vw group diesels if you can find one at the right price, I've done 15k in little over 6 months and its been completely faultless and bulletproof really. Its done 134k now and apart from consumables (ie rear pads) flew through its mot last week.

Ned.


muzchap - 12/7/06 at 04:43 PM

Focus Diesel or Seat Leon - the Focus has a slightly better quality interior - the Leon is a bit plasticy... IMHO!

Ford have put a lot into the Diesel Focus - handles well and goes forever.