Board logo

Tin top choice/dilema
Avoneer - 11/3/08 at 11:31 PM

Hi All,

£4k for a MK2 Renault Scenic with about 60k miles on it.

Or,

£6.5k for a MK3 (new shape) Renault Scenic with about 15k miles on it.

Does it justify the extra £2.5k.

We change car about every 3-4 years so in theory, the MK3 would be worth more for a trade in when it's due.

Cheers,

Pat...


onzarob - 11/3/08 at 11:35 PM

I work on the assumption that all car are worth half in 3 years.

So the 4 k one will of lost 2K, the 6.5K will of lost 3.25K

Running cost are approx the same


nick205 - 11/3/08 at 11:53 PM

If you hve the money then go for the newer car - someone else has already paid the big depreciation hit on it. If it's a case of borrowing the extra then go for the older one - 60k miles is really very little these days (even for a French car )


jlparsons - 12/3/08 at 01:35 AM

I'd go for the newer one. I tend to follow my old man's advice - about 6k is the right money to spend on a tintop. It's already taken the main hit in depreciation but it's only maybe a sixth of the way through it's (reliable) life, so the theory is that 6k is about the best value-for-money price point.

Complete rule of thumb, of course. But £2.5k for 45,000 extra miles ahead of you looks like a bargain to me.


britishtrident - 12/3/08 at 07:46 AM

With Renault diesel beware of turbo problems, change the oil at least every 10000 miles and use fully synth and let the engine idle for 15-30 seconds before switching off if the turbo is hot.

Usual caveats about french car electrical systems apply -- check everything is working.


speedyxjs - 12/3/08 at 07:52 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Avoneer
Does it justify the extra £2.5k.



Wont make much difference. They will both be just as unreliable.


COREdevelopments - 12/3/08 at 08:55 AM

speedyxjs has hit the nail on the head!!!!


speedyxjs - 12/3/08 at 09:12 AM


COREdevelopments - 12/3/08 at 10:07 AM

quote:
Originally posted by speedyxjs



thats it keep hitting it because these people who love french shite need to be told


speedyxjs - 12/3/08 at 10:52 AM