Board logo

sierra driveshaft swops?
billy - 6/1/06 at 04:22 PM

Hi chaps, i need to make new drive shafts up using a push-in joint on 1 end and a lobro bolt on, on the other end. im not sure if the splines are the same on both ends of the shaft when the joints are taken off? you need to cut the cover off the push in joints to split it, so i cant see if there the same. anyone done this???


Wadders - 6/1/06 at 04:36 PM

Hi
im in the process of doing something similar, and have cut open a tripode joint to examine the spline. Splines for lobros and tripode both fit the diff, but the lenghts are different, depending on what diff you have. To complicate matters further, LSD's have different length splines left to right.
I'll take some pictures and post them, it might make more sense.


dr-fastlane - 6/1/06 at 04:38 PM

Why not cut the two different driveshafts in half. And make a welding bush to connect the two driveshaft parts that you want to use.

Roy.


mookaloid - 6/1/06 at 04:42 PM

I've wondered about this myself, not sure if it can be done or not, It would mean fitting disc brakes to a previously drum braked setup would be easier.....

Mixing the types of joint on the shaft might not be a good idea - this is a gut feeling rather than an informed technical judgement though.

maybe some of the more tecnical bods on here have some thoughts.


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 04:45 PM

Hi mate,

Ive recently done this. I used 9" drum shafts from a 2.0 Sierra (not sure which model Im afraid) and CV joints from an XR4x4.
The joints were new but they dont come with the inner joint cover part (the bit which the inner gaiter fat end clips to), just the CV itself. The covers are no longer available from Ford so you need to get some from a pair of donor shafts (not a problem if your using second hand joints, theyll probably come with them). I bought a pair of Scorpio CV joints connected to about 6" of their shaft and the joints are the same as XR4x4.

The length of the splined section was different from the 2.0 to the Scorpio (shorter on the drum shaft) but there is sufficient length to fit the CV and circlip it.

The (Scorpio) lobro shafts had a longer splined portion and it was terminated on the inner side by a second circlip, the drum splines just run out onto the shaft.

The net result is the same width from CV to diff so that wasnt an issue.

The only problem I can see is finding the correct splined shafts as I found out today there are ones with fewer splines.

Would I do it again? Probably not. It was a fairly fiddly job finding all the bits and Im not convinced the work will be entirely worth the weight saving. I dont intend this to turn into a drums vs discs debate, but it cost me about 70 quid to fit new Lobro CVs to drum braked shafts to let me use them in an LSD.

The prime reason I did it was because I wanted to use an LSD and there were no shafts kicking about for that diff. Id also got a back end from a drum car so when I heard from Marty on the sierra owners club that he had done it and covered 3000 miles with it, I gave it a go.
Kind Rgds

Richie


[Edited on 6/1/06 by RichieC]


Wadders - 6/1/06 at 05:04 PM

Pics of shafts, the lobro pair are from a 3.62 lsd.
Tripode is from an open 3.38

http://locostbuilders.co.uk/photos.php?action=showphoto&photo=shafts1.jpg
http://locostbuilders.co.uk/photos.php?action=showphoto&photo=shafts2.jpg


Flat Pack - 6/1/06 at 05:16 PM

I'm in the process of doing this too

I can tell you the actual shaft part of the driveshaft can have at least 3 different sets of splines on it (I've now acquired 3 different sets of drive shafts and they're all different ).

1.3l cars have the smallest ones, I've not bothered to count the number of splines as it's plainly WRONG. It has tripode CV joints

I've got a set of shafts from a mk2 1.8l drum braked car, it has 22 splines on each end and tripode joints.

Finally I've got shafts from a 2.0 with rear discs. It's got 25 splines on each shaft and lobro joints.

Strangely enough I'd just u2u'ed RichieC about the very same thing, he said his tripode joints from a 2.0l Sierra with drums have 25 splines too.

So in summary, I think you need 2.0l drum braked outer joints (25 spline, got a feeling some are different) and inner joints from any disc braked non Cossie.

[Edited on 6/1/06 by Flat Pack]


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 05:18 PM

Yep, that sounds about right. I understood there to be one shaft spline for all non cossie sierras but that is not the case it seems.

I must have been lucky with the 2.0 sierra shafts combo.

Rgds

Rich


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 05:20 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Flat Pack

I've got a set of shafts from a mk2 1.8l drum braked car, it has 22 splines on each end and tripode joints.

Finally I've got shafts from a 2.0 with rear discs. It's got 25 splines on each shaft and lobro joints.
[Edited on 6/1/06 by Flat Pack]


Just to confirm, that is splines on the shaft not the tripode? Theres scope there to get mixed up cos I counted the splines on the tripode end outer (so the joint itself not the shaft inside it) and it has 28 splines at the drum end.

Rgds

Richie


Flat Pack - 6/1/06 at 05:23 PM

Wadders, from your pics it looks like you're talking about the spline that actually fits into the diff.

I think the question is about the splines on the end of the rod part of the shafts (certainly that's what I answered anyway!). The drive shafts we are trying to make up have a lobro joint at that end to connect to a LSD using the original splines into the diff and then a tripode joint at the wheel end to let use use drum hubs, carriers etc


Flat Pack - 6/1/06 at 05:25 PM

quote:
Originally posted by RichieC

Just to confirm, that is splines on the shaft not the tripode? Theres scope there to get mixed up cos I counted the splines on the tripode end outer (so the joint itself not the shaft inside it) and it has 28 splines at the drum end.

Rgds

Richie


Yes sorry, all those spline counts are for the 'rod' part of the drive shaft (I've also now butchered several drive shaft covers finding this out).


Wadders - 6/1/06 at 05:29 PM

Apologies, i misunderstood the first post.





Originally posted by Flat Pack
Wadders, from your pics it looks like you're talking about the spline that actually fits into the diff.

I think the question is about the splines on the end of the rod part of the shafts (certainly that's what I answered anyway!). The drive shafts we are trying to make up have a lobro joint at that end to connect to a LSD using the original splines into the diff and then a tripode joint at the wheel end to let use use drum hubs, carriers etc



RichieC - 6/1/06 at 05:33 PM

Exactomundo - the splines on the shaft once the joint has been removed.

Richie


steve_gus - 6/1/06 at 05:36 PM

i have had a shaft cut, modded and welded, but im not happy with it. The shafts are supposedly heat treated, and the welding might affect the strength.

That said, I think Luego do a sleeve to mod their own shafts......

I think someone on here (name escapes me right now nsdev? - a grasstracker) knows a company that can make a new shaft to suit for about 80 odd quid.

atb

steve


NS Dev - 6/1/06 at 05:58 PM

Yep, just reading the thread with interest!

Don't quite understand the weight issue and I prefer disc brakes to drums purely from a maintainance point of view (just my silly view, won't argue with drum favourers!)

Yes, there are a few shaft manufacturers about but the one who does all the grasstrack shafts is GB Engineering, and he will make shafts to suit the large or small ford Lobro joints to any length for £70 a piece. These are machined from billet and correctly heat-treated EN27 material, extremely tough, stronger than the std ford ones and MUCH lighter.

The CV's can easily be lightened by machining the excess material off the outer of the (Lobro type) CV cages, leaving the bolts exposed.................

where are the rest of the heavy bits on the disc setup and I will try and find more light bits!

I'm using the above setup on my 7.


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 06:02 PM

I cant remember the thread author but someone weighed them up. There is a marginal weight saving with drum setups vs discs.

The drum shafts are supposed to weigh less in themselves but to be quite honest there wasnt much in it; its just I didnt have rear discs from me donor parts.

I agree, discs would be my choice for looks but I suppose drums are cheaper.

Horses for courses - ah bugger I said I didnt want to turn it into a disc vs drum thing
Rgds

Richie


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 06:06 PM

tada

The saving is not so much in the brakes but in the inboard parts (negated obviously by fitting an LSD)
Rgds

Richie


NS Dev - 6/1/06 at 06:12 PM

OK, thought that was the case.

I need shorter shafts anyway as my car is "book track", so the custom made ones will get rid of the weight issue there and the lightened CV's should help too.


Flat Pack - 6/1/06 at 06:36 PM

Might just get some new ones made up to take my existing joints then Mine need shortening too and I'm not too keen on cutting and shutting the ends of 2 different ones as the shafts are all different thicknesses.

The only reason I wanted a tripode joint on the outside is because it's smaller diameter - I'd acquired some Golf calipers and Rally Design do a mounting kit to fit them to Sierra rear hubs. Unfortunately Lobro joints on the outside then foul the brake banjo...


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 06:44 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Flat Pack
The only reason I wanted a tripode joint on the outside is because it's smaller diameter - I'd acquired some Golf calipers and Rally Design do a mounting kit to fit them to Sierra rear hubs. Unfortunately Lobro joints on the outside then foul the brake banjo...

thats sounds interesting, anymore info on using golf calipers? Are they the hydraulic ones raldes do?

Rgds

Richie


Flat Pack - 6/1/06 at 07:06 PM

Yeap they're the hydra-mechanical ones from Rally Design. They've got a kit now (don't know if it made it to their website or not yet though) that consists of the 2 calipers, mounting brackets, discs and pads.

Seems to go together well enough, but I was one of the first people to get it from them and discovered this problem with lobro cv joints.


RichieC - 6/1/06 at 07:09 PM

Hmm, this could be the solution to allow a hydraulic handbrake setup

How much was the kit if you dont mine me asking

Cheers

Rich


Flat Pack - 6/1/06 at 07:19 PM

Kit was around £230 (not exactly locost!). The calipers have a mechanical handbrake mechanism (as required for SVA) so you need a cable handbrake still.

The calipers are lighter than Sierra ones and the handbrake mechanism is supposed to be better, not exactly had a chance to put that to the test yet though


billy - 6/1/06 at 07:35 PM

Ive cut and welded my original drive shafts twice now after the huge torque of the xe, and a heavy right foot has sheared the sleeve joint if there is a company who can make them up then thats the was to go. i found the diameter of the lobro ended shafts were a bit thicker so the sleeve was not as snug as id like 1 end, (when i mixed and matched) i need to keep the push in type joint at the wheel end as a lobro joint is to big to fit thro my de-dion tube Mr dev do you have there tel no for comany who makes the shaft?? cheers


Mansfield - 6/1/06 at 09:57 PM

I saw this in a car parts magazine.

http://www.cvjoints.co.uk/driveshafts.cfm

Ntdwm.


NS Dev - 9/1/06 at 11:17 AM

quote:
Originally posted by billy
Ive cut and welded my original drive shafts twice now after the huge torque of the xe, and a heavy right foot has sheared the sleeve joint if there is a company who can make them up then thats the was to go. i found the diameter of the lobro ended shafts were a bit thicker so the sleeve was not as snug as id like 1 end, (when i mixed and matched) i need to keep the push in type joint at the wheel end as a lobro joint is to big to fit thro my de-dion tube Mr dev do you have there tel no for comany who makes the shaft?? cheers


Geoff Berrisford is on 01270 841081

Not sure if he is tooled up to do the spline for the non-lobro end though, worth checking though. My shafts have always been lobro both ends so no idea on that one.

I was anticipating the same problem with my XE, and have seen a lot of broken shafts after welding on the back of grassers and the damage that they do, so £140 for a pair of nice purpose made shafts seems good value.

[Edited on 9/1/06 by NS Dev]