Board logo

towing with an A frame
mark.s - 12/8/10 at 07:40 PM

Can anyone tell me if it is legal to tow a kit car with an A frame with no tax or mot, i have had a look on the net and i'm more confused than when i started

i have read if its below 750kg which it will be, it is classed as a trailer, so is it happy days or ....


blakep82 - 12/8/10 at 07:42 PM

lol noooooo
if its got no tax and mot, its wheels mustn't touch the road. and a frames are for recovery only


JoelP - 12/8/10 at 07:52 PM

not strictly legal but you would likely get away with it provided you did everything else right like a trailer board and lights etc.


balidey - 12/8/10 at 07:56 PM

With no MOT, definitely not.
As for 'recovery only' or 'car becomes classed as a trailer' then those two statements are not strictly true.
The 'evidence' these claims come from are guidelines only. I have yet to find the law that states they are legal or illegal.

Rather than retype, here is what I have previously written...

http://www.locostbuilders.co.uk/viewthread.php?tid=124051


mookaloid - 12/8/10 at 08:03 PM

How do these motorhomes that tow a smart car behind them on an A frame manage to be legal then?


Humbug - 12/8/10 at 08:06 PM

quote:
Originally posted by mookaloid
How do these motorhomes that tow a smart car behind them on an A frame manage to be legal then?


Presumably because the Smart has tax and MOT?


JoelP - 12/8/10 at 08:06 PM

quote:
Originally posted by mookaloid
How do these motorhomes that tow a smart car behind them on an A frame manage to be legal then?


allegedly they are not, but apaprently no one has ever been prosecuted.

It would weight more than 750kgs so needs brakes, but IIRC overrun brakes can only be used on a centre axle trailer.

[Edited on 12/8/10 by JoelP]


balidey - 12/8/10 at 08:06 PM

quote:
Originally posted by mookaloid
How do these motorhomes that tow a smart car behind them on an A frame manage to be legal then?


They are legal because..... its NOT illegal.

Why is eating chips legal? Because its not illegal etc etc


balidey - 12/8/10 at 08:11 PM

quote:
Originally posted by JoelP

It would weight more than 750kgs so needs brakes, but IIRC overrun brakes can only be used on a centre axle trailer.

[Edited on 12/8/10 by JoelP]


Nope, if you read my link to previous post above, the requirement for brakes over 750kg is for a TRAILER. A towed car is not a trailer. But the DfT have issues guidelines saying they believe its a trailer. Two inaccurate points. 1 'we believe' and 2, its a trailer. Its not ,its a car being towed.

The law needs to change to make it either illegal, or make it clearer that its legal.


JoelP - 12/8/10 at 08:18 PM

well if its a car being towed, then the fact it has no mot would reflect on the driver of that car, and since theres no driver, the only charge i can think of would be 'driving without due driver'.

Must say though, i would count it as a trailer, simply because there is no driver. And even as a towed car, from a safety aspect it still should be braked.

But as i said, i wouldnt be bothered myself.


balidey - 12/8/10 at 08:24 PM

I know a few people that use them. my brother in law uses his every day. He has been pulled over several times, even had prohibition orders put on his van and towed car. Yet every single time he is let off and sent on his way. Why? Because when you start investigating it, there appears to be no law (and I have looked properly) that states they are illegal, or even a law that states a towed car is classed as a trailer.

So as long as the towed car is MOT'ed taxed and (I think) insured, then it appears they are OK to use for everyday transportation.

But as I have said before, I would love to be proved wrong, so then i can stop looking for the law that says they are illegal.


gavin174 - 12/8/10 at 08:35 PM

my parents tow a smart behind behind their motorhome on an A frame

but there is a connection to the smarts brakes..

i believe its an electrical connection to a solenoid on the master cylinder some how.


myke pocock - 12/8/10 at 09:40 PM

Have a look here for trailer regs:- http://www.dft.gov.uk/pgr/roads/vehicles/vssafety/requirementsfortrailers
As far as I am aware, when you use an A frame the vehicle that you are towing effectively becomes a trailer and as such requires brakes which are connected to the braking system of the towing vehicle (but see the regs regarding towing and towed vehicle weights etc) . I used to A frame my Skoda Estelle trials car but now take it on a trailer. Regarding mobile homes and towing vehicles, if you look at the likes of Brian James, Ifor Williams etc you will notce that they are now making small trailers specifically for the likes of Smart cars and similar. It was rumoured that plod was getting very interested in vehicles being towed on the M6 a while back. Where do I live? On the end of the M6


zilspeed - 12/8/10 at 10:34 PM

Every thread you will ever read on every forum past present and future on the internet, on this subject, will all have the same content.

It's a car being towed / it's a trailer / 750kg unbraked / auto reverse brakes / recovery / MOT / tax / insurance / blah blah.

A very very very long time ago (let's say 26, 27 years ago) , I went to an evening in a local Ford main dealers being held by a local car club. There were various competition cars there and we were particularly interested in the autotest mini special.

We asked him how he transported it.

His response.

"Yeah, I used to A frame it, but I got fed up getting pulled by the police. Some said, it was legal, some said they weren't sure, some reckoned it was illegal but they weren't sure why."

In the end, even though he never actually got a ticket for it, the constant 'attention' was sufficient for him to give it up.
He ended up with a trailer.

To be fair though, if you're towing at all these days, I would expect either the police or, increasingly, VOSA to take an interest in what you're up to and want to check your whole setup over.

Your call.


Ninehigh - 13/8/10 at 06:59 AM

quote:
Originally posted by JoelP
well if its a car being towed, then the fact it has no mot would reflect on the driver of that car, and since theres no driver, the only charge i can think of would be 'driving without due driver'.


Who would they send the ticket to?

DO10: Driving whilst outside of the vehicle

[Edited on 13/8/10 by Ninehigh]


matt_claydon - 13/8/10 at 09:38 AM

There are any number of bits of legislation, including C&U that define trailer as:

quote:

"trailer" means a vehicle drawn by a motor vehicle



There are rules for trailers, some of which are specifically exempted when the trailer is a 'broken down vehicle'. e.g. requirements for approval marks on reflectors:
quote:

(b) A trailer (other than a broken-down motor vehicle) manufactured:
(i) On or after 1st October 1989:

An approval mark incorporating "III" or "IIIA"




So it seems pretty clear that in law, a vehicle towed behind another one is a trailer.

[Edited on 13/8/10 by matt_claydon]