Board logo

Topic Suggestion
Mix - 26/1/04 at 03:13 PM

Having just read Donut's post on his test and sympathising with him that he came so close to a first time pass I wondered if it would be a useful resource to have a topic devoted to the reasons people have failed their SVA test. Over time this could become a good 'aide memoire' for others presenting cars for inspection. After all we could all benefit from the experiences of others at this rather stressful time.

How about it Chris?

Mick


liam.mccaffrey - 26/1/04 at 03:22 PM

that would be an absolutely fantastic resource. I bet it would cut down on SVA failures big time!

It would allow ppl to address popular fail points during their build and not at the test centre!

[Edited on 26/1/04 by liam.mccaffrey]


JAG - 26/1/04 at 04:45 PM

Excellent idea. Would this be a thread in the "SVA/Legal" area or would we want another area???

Certainly would help reduce failure rates!


Simon - 26/1/04 at 04:58 PM

Great idea, but, I think it would need to be an updatable spreadsheet. That way, it would not get diluted by off topic threads etc etc.

ATB

Simon


GO - 26/1/04 at 05:03 PM

Its an ideal candidate for the wiki that Chris was looking into.

Chris, any news with that?


ChrisW - 26/1/04 at 08:11 PM

quote:
Originally posted by GO
Its an ideal candidate for the wiki that Chris was looking into.

Chris, any news with that?


As I wrote in the website problems section, I'm a little worried if people will use it. Can I have a show of hands please??

Chris


Deckman001 - 26/1/04 at 08:20 PM

How about everyone about to take their sva !!

Jason


chrisg - 26/1/04 at 08:20 PM

What's a wiki?

If it's one o' them french stand up toilets then I won't be using it.

Cheers

Chris


macspeedy - 26/1/04 at 08:39 PM

brilliant idea


Kitlooney1000 - 26/1/04 at 09:36 PM

Would be extremely useful if we had a resource such as this, common faults would then be a thing of the past. I would certainly use it.


blueshift - 26/1/04 at 10:56 PM

Bung the wiki up and see if people use it

sounds like a great idea to me. I'd bung one up myself but it would be better on this site that everyone comes to already.


ChrisW - 26/1/04 at 11:23 PM

Looks like I'm having my arm well and truely twisted!

Chris


GO - 26/1/04 at 11:39 PM

knee in the back, twist a litle further...

I would defo use it, at least to read, nowhere near sva yet!


David Jenkins - 27/1/04 at 08:42 AM

quote:
Originally posted by chrisg
If it's one o' them french stand up toilets then I won't be using it.



Why? Do you have to use the sit-down toilets?



David


Mix - 27/1/04 at 09:54 AM

I'm not sure how a WIKI works or even what it is but to expand a little on my initial thoughts,

The 'topic' (is that the right term?), would be more of a list, each entry listing reasons for failing the test, where the test was carried out and any points raised during the test by the examiner etc. I don't think it should become a general discussion area as this would tend to dilute the information. Points provoking further discusion could be continued in their appropriate area.

Please don't think I'm trying to tell Chris how to do his bit, these are just the thoughts of an IT imbecile.

Mick

I think I really mean a new forum and not topic, is that the right terminology ?

[Edited on 27/1/04 by Mix]

[Edited on 27/1/04 by Mix]


blueshift - 27/1/04 at 01:09 PM

A wiki is a kind of freeform web information thingy that anyone (depending how you set it up) can edit. It remembers what was done so if someone comes in and maliciously trashes it you can roll it back to when it was good. I think there are various more complicated access and version controls too.

It's often used for things like FAQs, people put up questions and others can answer them or edit / refine / add to the answers.

I think it would be an excellent way of storing lots of those useful locost tidbits that get lost in the forum archives; all the book errors, cymtriks mods, links to jim mcsorley's stuff, etc etc.


JoelP - 27/1/04 at 02:36 PM

i aint got much useful to say, but rest assured if i feel the need to post something i would! plus im gonna be a good contributor to the 'why i failed the sva test' section!!!


blueshift - 27/1/04 at 04:21 PM

quote:
Originally posted by JoelP
i aint got much useful to say, but rest assured if i feel the need to post something i would!

That's not really in the spirit of a good wiki. The idea is you get a good information source with high signal to noise ratio, not a load of people filling it up with bollocks.


JoelP - 27/1/04 at 05:26 PM

believe it or not, i do try to avoid talking shite usually...