Board logo

Anyone like to justify this???
myke pocock - 29/7/13 at 06:42 PM

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/9063200/NHS-spends-23m-a-year-on-translators.html

SOFT TOUCH UK AGAIN!!!


scootz - 29/7/13 at 06:52 PM

Because a handful of lawsuits brought about through a 'breakdown in communication' would probably cost the NHS more???


ReMan - 29/7/13 at 06:56 PM

It can't be

And I take a very christian view that any genuine visitors to the country should be cared for appropriately and for free whilst in our land and as such may have difficulty in such an emergency European or otherwise. But I dont believe emergency cases would rack up that bill, 1 % maybe


puma931 - 29/7/13 at 07:05 PM

Perhaps we should be investing in teaching languages at school.
Us English are the worst at speaking 2nd or 3rd languages and rely on other nationalities speaking English when we are abroad.


iank - 29/7/13 at 07:22 PM

Should just let all the deaf people die then... oh didn't you realise that budget also pays for all the sign language interpreters that are needed and there being significantly fewer of them and having to be present in the surgery/hospital means I bet the lions share goes to them.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/may/07/lack-interpreters-deaf-people-risk

[Edited on 29/7/13 by iank]


AndyW - 29/7/13 at 07:28 PM

As there are 353 current NHS hospitals in England, £64000 per day spread over all nhs hospitals isn't that much being spend per hospital as you might think. Let's see what we pay to lazy arse, cant be bothered to get a job, scroungers each day, whilst we go out to a hard days work to support them????


coyoteboy - 29/7/13 at 07:41 PM

Indeed that's £181 per day per hospital - which would be about 2 hours worth of a decent interpreters time. I'm surprised that's not the daily wail that's being quoted.


Wadders - 29/7/13 at 07:43 PM

Heard a similar thing on the radio today, who knows if it's true but apparently the last government decided to rationalise fire

emergency response centres and created about a dozen regional offices to co ordinate things, after a disaster with implementing IT

systems which cost billions the idea was abandoned leaving around 4 brand new buildings empty.........cost to us the taxpayer to

maintain said buildings...... 4 million a month

I'm thinking someone is getting very rich from those empty properties, it would be cheaper to fell the things and cut the taxpayers losses.

No wonder the country is in such a state.


myke pocock - 29/7/13 at 07:52 PM

Wadders, I believe that one of those over in the North East is to be taken over and used by......... the local fire service. Well I never!!!!!


theconrodkid - 29/7/13 at 07:52 PM

as someone who works for the NHS i can tell you that a lot of people treated have no right for that treatment,they have come here just for the free house/money/healthcare.
like the one with 3 wives and 15 kids who live in 3 council flats and not one of them work,the old man is on dyalasis that costs a fortune to adminsiter,he dosnt speak a word of english as everything is handed to him/them on a plate,or the one who arrived at the hospital direct from the airport for her dyalasis to start...how did that happen ?.
if i went to another country and need healthcare or to speak to the local authoroty i would have to speak the lingo or get my own translater so why provide them free here ?.


jeffw - 29/7/13 at 08:13 PM

Is this to translate what all the foreign, non-English speaking medical staff are saying to their English speaking patients or the other way round?


coyoteboy - 29/7/13 at 08:20 PM

quote:
Originally posted by theconrodkid
as someone who works for the NHS i can tell you that a lot of people treated have no right for that treatment,they have come here just for the free house/money/healthcare.
like the one with 3 wives and 15 kids who live in 3 council flats and not one of them work,the old man is on dyalasis that costs a fortune to adminsiter,he dosnt speak a word of english as everything is handed to him/them on a plate,or the one who arrived at the hospital direct from the airport for her dyalasis to start...how did that happen ?.
if i went to another country and need healthcare or to speak to the local authoroty i would have to speak the lingo or get my own translater so why provide them free here ?.



Anyone who works for the NHS would know there's specialist teams whos job it is to hunt down such people and ensure the treatment is paid for. I know quite a few doctors working in NHS hospitals who say it's a reasonably rare event?


myke pocock - 29/7/13 at 08:25 PM

.....£181 per day per hospital - which would be about 2 hours worth of a decent interpreters time


£90 per hour for an interpreter??? And you recon thats a reasonable rate??? Your avin a laugh mate!


iank - 29/7/13 at 08:52 PM

quote:
Originally posted by myke pocock
.....£181 per day per hospital - which would be about 2 hours worth of a decent interpreters time


£90 per hour for an interpreter??? And you recon thats a reasonable rate??? Your avin a laugh mate!


Have you seen what you get charged by the hour for a main-stealers grease monkey? If there's no real market that's what you'll pay in the private sector, what the market can bear.


scootz - 29/7/13 at 09:06 PM

quote:
Originally posted by myke pocock
.....£181 per day per hospital - which would be about 2 hours worth of a decent interpreters time

£90 per hour for an interpreter??? And you recon that's a reasonable rate??? You're avin a laugh mate!



Don't think anyone would consider it to be a reasonable rate, but I also don't think Mike will be all that far off with his guess as I remember 'Language Line' costing an absolute fortune back in the 90's... and that was all done over the phone! Factor in a 'call out' fee and it starts to rise further!

The translation providers know it's an essential service, so they can pretty much name their price (especially for agencies who can't waste time waiting like the NHS and Police).

I don't think you can blame the NHS for this one...


SteveWalker - 29/7/13 at 10:00 PM

My wife works with the mentally ill. The area she works in is predominantly inhabited by immigrants. She has many genuinely ill patients, but also a significant proportion of obvious spongers. Many of these spongers speak good English, but suddenly struggle whenever they are challenged about their own actions, ability to work, etc. Suddenly they require an interpreter - at £200 an hour, with a minimum booking period of 3 hours! This tends to happen particularly when their DLA is due for re-evaluation - and once it is confirmed, they suddenly manage to speak English again or not bother making any of their appointments until the next time their benefits are at risk.


theconrodkid - 30/7/13 at 06:06 AM

quote:Originally posted by theconrodkid
as someone who works for the NHS i can tell you that a lot of people treated have no right for that treatment,they have come here just for the free house/money/healthcare.
like the one with 3 wives and 15 kids who live in 3 council flats and not one of them work,the old man is on dyalasis that costs a fortune to adminsiter,he dosnt speak a word of english as everything is handed to him/them on a plate,or the one who arrived at the hospital direct from the airport for her dyalasis to start...how did that happen ?.
if i went to another country and need healthcare or to speak to the local authoroty i would have to speak the lingo or get my own translater so why provide them free here ?.



Anyone who works for the NHS would know there's specialist teams whos job it is to hunt down such people and ensure the treatment is paid for. I know quite a few doctors working in NHS hospitals who say it's a reasonably rare event?



Here in London,it happens all the time,how do you track down someone who lives in a mud hut in the middle of nowhere or gives a false address ?.


Peteff - 30/7/13 at 09:04 AM

quote:
Originally posted by theconrodkidHere in London,it happens all the time,how do you track down someone who lives in a mud hut in the middle of nowhere or gives a false address ?.


Make them do same as everyone else. I just had to produce my driving license, log book and a recent service bill just to buy a number plate


swanny - 30/7/13 at 11:00 AM

as an aside... when you initially see the 17% increase this is quite shocking, yet it actually appears to be less than the rate of inflation over the same period. data

nice bit of journalism there.


Ninehigh - 30/7/13 at 03:45 PM

£90 an hour for a translator? There's an app for that


owelly - 30/7/13 at 04:07 PM

How much it be for an online video link to the relevant embassy or language school?!


jossey - 30/7/13 at 06:40 PM

In defence of this rather than justification.... I've been to many countries n the hospitals will have interpreters for me n the English etc...


coozer - 30/7/13 at 06:41 PM

VOTE UKIP


JoelP - 30/7/13 at 08:04 PM

quote:
Originally posted by coozer
VOTE UKIP


You must be joking!


coyoteboy - 30/7/13 at 08:15 PM

I don't think £90 is a bad hourly rate for a potentially highly skilled multilingual person who may well have to have medical background to properly translate, when you factor in call out fees and the usual hike in price for contract work (due to them having unpredictable income).

I've seen folk pay £85 per hour at normal car main dealers before now, and that's for a chap with a spanner.


myke pocock - 30/7/13 at 09:15 PM

Oh realy, get real. You cannot in any way equate a translators wage and the costs involved with that of a main dealer and the costs of running such an establishment. As we are recounting stories heres mine. A colleagues wife worked in an NHS call centre in the North East. It wasnt unusual to receive a call from someone who was wanting to claim benefit and couldnt speak Eenglish and needed a translator. The initial call to said translator was charged as £25 then subsequent minutes were paid at £10 per minute. Also it wasnt unusual that a call ended for some spurious reason meaning a further call to the translator who was then paid a further £25. Real story or fairy tale? When disabled people needing an additional bedroom for entirely legitimate reasons (storage of equipment, sleeping for a disabled partner as on the news tonight) are being denied legitimate benefit surely spurious use of the translator system should be clamped down on. AND for those who may get all defensive I will readily accept the LEGITIMATE translator system in the NHS>


Simon - 30/7/13 at 10:57 PM

quote:
Originally posted by JoelP
quote:
Originally posted by coozer
VOTE UKIP


You must be joking!


Er, no! Not if we could guarantee labour wouldn't return. Still, if Scotland votes for independence then that's about 48 labour MPs removed from the equation. And the lib dems can then p/off too as they'll be surplus to tory requirements!

My view on people coming to this country is to welcome them with open arms on the understanding that the reason they came here is because it's better than their own country. The reasons usually boil down to politics and god, so leave yours at home and try our way, or you'll drag this country to the same state you left yours, then bugger off somewhere else to do the same thing leaving us with a great pile to clear up. People who are on the (eg medical) scrounge can be sent packing, after they've been treated and their embassy has paid the bill.

It's all very well saying the British should learn a foreign language, but which one - usual three French, German or Spanish? Italian perhaps. Emerging markets might be a better idea - but which Indian or Chinese language. Russian, Japanese or Korean perhaps. Maybe do Gallic just in case the Scots go independent or Welsh - always liked the accent.

I agree we should be better, but then I think we are in the uniquely enviable position that everyone uses English - all marine and aviation etc. We are the langauge common denominator for the rest of the world and I don't think that's a bad thing - we just got lucky.

ATB

Simon


scootz - 31/7/13 at 12:09 AM

quote:
Originally posted by myke pocock
As we are recounting stories heres mine. A colleagues wife worked in an NHS call centre in the North East. It wasnt unusual to receive a call from someone who was wanting to claim benefit and couldnt speak Eenglish and needed a translator....



Why would a man wanting to claim benefits be calling an NHS call-centre... ???


coyoteboy - 31/7/13 at 07:25 AM

quote:

Oh realy, get real. You cannot in any way equate a translators wage and the costs involved with that of a main dealer and the costs of running such an establishment



A) If the costs of running a main dealer mean a mechanic had to be charged at 85 an hour they have a very poor business model.
B) I'm not trying to equate them, I'm using them as a reference to show the 90 isn't a million miles apart from sanity and if you consider you pay for skill, experience and availability rather than buildings you will see the original figure in the OP isn't particularly high.
If we are looking at who is the most value for their wage it becomes debateable
Based on your background and beliefs, but that is a whole other argument that isn't relevant herr.


Ninehigh - 31/7/13 at 07:44 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Simon
It's all very well saying the British should learn a foreign language, but which one - usual three French, German or Spanish? Italian perhaps. Emerging markets might be a better idea - but which Indian or Chinese language. Russian, Japanese or Korean perhaps. Maybe do Gallic just in case the Scots go independent or Welsh - always liked the accent.




Polish is the second most popular language in the country apparently. It caused a bit of a ruckus with the dail mail lot but the second language has got to be a foreign one!


scudderfish - 31/7/13 at 09:58 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Ninehigh
Polish is the second most popular language in the country apparently. It caused a bit of a ruckus with the dail mail lot but the second language has got to be a foreign one!


Unless the worst fears of the DM happen


britishtrident - 31/7/13 at 10:36 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Ninehigh
quote:
Originally posted by Simon
It's all very well saying the British should learn a foreign language, but which one - usual three French, German or Spanish? Italian perhaps. Emerging markets might be a better idea - but which Indian or Chinese language. Russian, Japanese or Korean perhaps. Maybe do Gallic just in case the Scots go independent or Welsh - always liked the accent.




Polish is the second most popular language in the country apparently. It caused a bit of a ruckus with the daily mail lot but the second language has got to be a foreign one!


Polish was the second language in Fife during WW2 because so many Polish exiles were stationed there and many settled there during the Cold War , 70 years on things are back to normal just a scattering of mainly anglicised Polish surnames to show for it.

In my area what I really really object to is the foisting of bilingual English-Gaelic signs on every rail station in every part of Scotland, the area I live in was never a Gaelic speaking area they actually have to invent Gaelic versions of the place names but we have to have them because of a tiny but vocal pressure group.

[Edited on 31/7/13 by britishtrident]


britishtrident - 31/7/13 at 10:39 AM

quote:
Originally posted by scudderfish
quote:
Originally posted by Ninehigh
Polish is the second most popular language in the country apparently. It caused a bit of a ruckus with the dail mail lot but the second language has got to be a foreign one!


Unless the worst fears of the DM happen



Yeah but DM readers would be happy that at least they could find a decent plumber or nanny.


myke pocock - 31/7/13 at 12:38 PM

Sorry Sootz, DSS. Its an age thing SEE!!!


scootz - 31/7/13 at 12:52 PM

Ah!


Simon - 31/7/13 at 10:29 PM

quote:
Originally posted by britishtrident
In my area what I really really object to is the foisting of bilingual English-Gaelic signs on every rail station in every part of Scotland, the area I live in was never a Gaelic speaking area they actually have to invent Gaelic versions of the place names but we have to have them because of a tiny but vocal pressure group.

[Edited on 31/7/13 by britishtrident]


It'll be Cornish signs next. I'm gonna invent Kentish Just for a laugh, when I was in north Wales recently, I tuned into a Welsh speaking radio station - no idea what they were saying, but quite a high percentage of the words were English. Quite funny really.

ATB

Simon


scudderfish - 1/8/13 at 05:28 AM

I used to work with a South African couple who would have stand-up domestics in the middle of the office. They'd rant at each other in Afrikaans, but swear at each other in English. Quite amusing